9 January 2025 in Perspectives on Medical Education
Background: Medical students regularly report poorer mental health outcomes than students from other faculties and in other degree programmes. Gender and year of study have been discussed as factors influencing mental health. However, study results for both factors are inconclusive. Moreover, little is known about the associations between gender and study progression with perceived study demands. Methods: >The purpose of this study was to analyse medical students’ self-reported mental health status and perceived study demands with particular focus on gender differences and study progression. We conducted an online survey in two German universities across three data collection waves during the winter terms of the academic years 2021, 2022, and 2023. We included 1,083 medical students (73% women) in our analyses: bivariate t-tests and ANOVAs with gender, study progression, and university as predictors of depression, exhaustion, six dimensions of study demands, and satisfaction with learning and study. Results: Our results demonstrated gender differences regarding mental health and study demands, favouring men on all outcomes in t-tests and ANOVAs. We did not find differences between beginners and advanced students in mental health, but beginners reported greater difficulty with performance pressure and self-structuring. Conclusions: Our findings confirm persistent gender differences in mental health and study demands, with women reporting higher distress. We did not find differences in terms of satisfaction with studies or learning. To improve medical students’ well-being, we suggest targeted interventions for vulnerable groups using gender-sensitive approaches and designs. Beginners likely benefit from support with self-structuring and managing performance pressure.
27 August 2024 in Journal of Public Health
Aim: Medical students regularly report high study demands and low mental health. Both demands and mental health can be influenced by the curricular structure of degree programmes. We thus studied medical students in two different curricula in Germany, investigating their study demands, study and life satisfaction, and overall and mental health, with emphasis on contrasting beginners and advanced students. Subject and methods: We used online surveys with convenience samples through university mailing lists and student union channels. Uni1 participants ( N = 357; 70% female; M = 24.83 years) were older than Uni2 participants ( N = 126; 79% female; M = 23.39 years), but the cohorts did not differ further regarding sociodemographic variables. The main outcomes were study demands on six dimensions, study and life satisfaction, and overall and mental health. For analyses, we used t -tests for comparisons and correlations for associations. Results: Students of both universities reported good mental and overall health as well as high satisfaction with their studies and lives, although sleep difficulties were prevalent. Study demands were low to medium, with the highest demands being learning activities ( M = 5.31; SD = 2.19, scale 0–10), self-structuring ( M = 4.61; SD = 2.01), and performance pressure ( M = 4.45; SD = 2.27). The students in the reformed degree programme reported fewer issues with integrating theory and practice than those in the regular degree programme ( M Uni1 = 3.38; SD Uni1 = 2.05; M Uni2 = 4.17; SD Uni2 = 2.06; t (430) = −3.53, p < .001). Conclusion: Our sample was rather resilient regarding mental health and coping with study demands. The two universities showed little to no differences. With relative increased demands regarding learning activities, self-structuring, and performance pressure, we suggest focusing on learning strategies for beginners and strategies for stress reduction to address, among other things, the reported sleep difficulties.