8 June 2024 in Empirical Software Engineering
Identifying security issues early is encouraged to reduce the latent negative impacts on the software systems. Code review is a widely-used method that allows developers to manually inspect modified code, catching security issues during a software development cycle. However, existing code review studies often focus on known vulnerabilities, neglecting coding weaknesses, which can introduce real-world security issues that are more visible through code review. The practices of code reviews in identifying such coding weaknesses are not yet fully investigated. To better understand this, we conducted an empirical case study in two large open-source projects, OpenSSL and PHP. Based on 135,560 code review comments, we found that reviewers raised security concerns in 35 out of 40 coding weakness categories. Surprisingly, some coding weaknesses related to past vulnerabilities, such as memory errors and resource management, were discussed less often than the vulnerabilities. Developers attempted to address raised security concerns in many cases (39%-41%), but a substantial portion was merely acknowledged (30%-36%), and some went unfixed due to disagreements about solutions (18%-20%). This highlights that coding weaknesses can slip through code review even when identified. Our findings suggest that reviewers can identify various coding weaknesses leading to security issues during code reviews. However, these results also reveal shortcomings in current code review practices, indicating the need for more effective mechanisms or support for increasing awareness of security issue management in code reviews.
24 April 2026 in ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology
Modern code review is a ubiquitous software quality assurance process aimed at identifying and resolving potential issues (e.g., functional, evolvability) within newly written code. Despite its effectiveness, the process demands large amounts of effort from the human reviewers involved. To help alleviate this workload, researchers have trained various deep learning-based language models to imitate human reviewers in providing natural language code reviews for submitted code. Formally, this automation task is known as code review comment generation. Prior work has demonstrated improvements in code review comment generation by leveraging machine learning techniques and neural models, such as transfer learning and the transformer architecture. However, the quality of the model-generated reviews remains sub-optimal due to the quality of the open-source code review data used in model training. This is in part due to the data obtained from open-source projects where code reviews are conducted in a public forum, and reviewers possess varying levels of software development experience, potentially affecting the quality of their feedback. To accommodate this variation, we propose a suite of experience-aware training methods that utilise the reviewers’ past authoring and reviewing experiences as signals for review quality. Specifically, we propose experience-aware loss functions (ELF), which use the reviewers’ authoring and reviewing ownership of a project as weights in the model’s loss function. Through this method, experienced reviewers’ code reviews yield larger influence over the model’s behaviour. Compared to the SOTA model, ELF was able to generate higher quality reviews in terms of accuracy (e.g., +29% applicable comments), informativeness (e.g., +56% suggestions), and issue types discussed (e.g., +129% functional issues identified). The key contribution of this work is the demonstration of how traditional software engineering concepts such as reviewer experience can be integrated into the design of AI-based automated code review models.