Crowdsourcing of rainfall measurements incorporating common citizens as a rich source of data is an emerging concept with huge potential to provide valuable high spatiotemporal resolution rainfall observations. Here we investigate the merging of crowdsourced rainfall data with traditional radar and rain gauge data to maximize their utility. For this purpose, we develop a tailored fast Bayesian regression kriging (FBRK) method combining regression kriging and Laplace approximation in a Bayesian framework. A strength of the FBRK method lies in its ability to capture the differences between rain gauge and crowdsourced measurement errors. Another lies in its fast yet reasonably accurate approximation of the Bayesian posterior, making it suitable to use in real time. We conduct synthetic computer simulations to evaluate the FBRK method alongside three other merging methods. In the simulations, we compare the accuracies of their resulting rainfall estimates, as well as the skill of those estimates as input to a storm water flow forecasting model. In both aspects, we observe the FBRK method to lead to more accurate results and truer representations of the associated uncertainties. However, we also observe the performance of the FBRK method to be sensitive to the choice of the Bayesian prior under certain conditions. Finally, from the synthetic simulations, we find merging crowdsourced data with traditional data to lead to more accurate estimation of the ground truth rainfall field and, subsequently, more accurate flow forecasts (though only when an adequate merging method, e.g., the FBRK method, is used), and the results to be fairly robust to bias in the input crowdsourced data.
1 June 2004 in Journal of Environmental Engineering
Many jurisdictions in the United States are currently preparing total maximum daily load (TMDL) programs for stream segments that come under Section 303(d) of the Clean Water Act. Among the options being considered by many state pollution control agencies is that of permit trading, otherwise known as permit transfers, transferable permits, emissions trading, bubbles, pollution rights, marketable effluent permits, and transferable discharge permits. Under such programs, a permit to discharge into a watercourse, issued as part of a wasteload allocation program, is treated as a marketable commodity. This paper presents a qualitative discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of permit trading in the context of a TMDL program, and discusses the circumstances that favor it. The paper also presents hypothetical quantitative findings to illustrate the circumstances under which a regional administrator might wish to adopt a program of permit trading, and if so, what type of permits would suit it best.