This paper undertakes a critical analysis of recent education and curriculum policies in Portugal, focusing on the relationship between globalization, international agencies, and the curriculum. It aims to highlight not only changes in the organization of schools, but also the setting of a agenda structured at a global level for education in which the ability of supranational and transnational institutional forces to cross or go beyond national borders and the configuration of relationships between nations are all implicit. The paper contends that education and curriculum policies should be understood as a product of multiple influences and interdependencies; they are the result of a process of bricolage which reveals the interests, values, principles, and rules that, at any given moment, are dominant or not. Drawing upon this approach, the aim is to show, on the one hand, how the results of the large OECD research projects influence educational and curriculum policy‐making in Portugal, and, on the other hand, how these policies are affected by the ‘Europeanization’ process.
This article examines the OECD’s role in the construction of education policies in Portugal after the Second World War up to the Carnation Revolution (1974). For a large part of the twentieth century (1926–1974), Portugal lived under a nationalist dictatorship, with elements that were on a par with the European fascism. After analysing the genesis of the OECD (OEEC, as originally established), this article describes how participating in the Mediterranean Regional Programme, designed and conducted by the OECD/OEEC between 1960 and 1968, was important to integrate Portugal in the western sphere of influence, and enabled the creation of the basis for an education policy which would represent the most important source of mandate and legitimacy for the developmentalist positions and proposals arising from the technocratic sectors of the regime which, increasingly, gained influence in the economic departments and in the offices of education planning and labour force training in the 1960s and early 1970s. Abbreviation: Mediterranean Regional Project (MRP/PRM)
29 May 2017 in RASE: Revista de la Asociación de Sociología de la Educación
En el presente texto se revisa desde una perspectiva crítica la construcción de sistemas transnacionales de evaluación de la calidad a través de los rankings internacionales. En la primera parte, reflexionamos sobre el concepto de calidad y presentamos diferentes tipos de rankings: los denominados League Tables (ARWU, THE, QS) y los centrados en resultados de investigación (SCImago Institutions Ranking). Una vez conocidas las características y posibles utilidades de los mismos, analizamos dialógicamente una serie de riesgos a tener en cuenta para acabar incidiendo de nuevo en el modelo de calidad que proponen y sus posibles efectos.
In this paper two of the better-known university rankings produced internationally are considered, the Academic Ranking World Universities (ARWU) and the Times Higher Education World Universities Rankings (THE), as well as a national ranking, the Folha University Ranking (RUF), focussed on Brazilian universities. The thesis we put forward is that rankings play a dual role, regulating the market and disseminating organizational models. The paper highlights the existence of differences between the concerns (and implications) of the international rankings (ARWU and THE) and the Brazilian national ranking (RUF), which sets out as main goals, on the one hand, to steer the elites’ demand for tertiary education towards degrees with higher employability and, on the other, to provide indications which may be considered useful for the labour market to recruit better qualified professionals. Keywords: Brazil; universities; rankings; regulation; labour market.
Cet article procède à une analyse des rapports entre les organisations internationales (de nature intergouvernementale) et la formulation des politiques d’éducation au niveau national. On s’argumente que, avec l’affirmation d’un projet de développement global – la globalisation, émergent des nouvelles formes de régulation transnationales qui ont comme centre névralgique les grands projets statistiques de comparaison international, notamment ceux qui sont développés au sein de l’OCDE. Après faire la distinction entre une globalisation de haute intensité au niveau des processus rapides, intenses, ayant une seule cause, et une globalisation de basse intensité au niveau des procès plus lents et diffus et plus ambigus quant à leur causalité, on se permette considérer l’éducation un cas possible et paradigmatique d’une globalisation de basse intensité, ce qui peut renforcer les conditions pour affirmer des politiques et des pratiques émancipatrices au champ éducative.
Neste artigo apresentamos uma análise comparativa entre três inquéritos internacionais: PISA, levado a cabo pela OCDE, o TIMSS e o PIRLS, realizados pela IEA, tendo em conta os seus objetivos gerais e uma correlação dos dados referentes a Portugal (por regiões da NUTS III). A revisão bibliográfica e documental mostrou como os resultados podem ser reformulados ou reinterpretados pelos diferentes atores sociais e que são vistos pelos decisores políticos e pelas organizações como uma ferramenta de comparação dos sistemas escolares, reveladora de pontos fortes e pontos fracos. A análise dos resultados gerais evidencia que Portugal tem vindo a melhorar os seus resultados no PISA, nos três domínios (leitura, matemática e ciências), que melhorou no TIMSS em matemática e piorou em leitura no PIRLS. A análise comparativa por regiões revelou que existe uma diferenciação dos resultados por regiões e que, enquanto o fator domínio não se apresenta como relevante, o fator objeto de avaliação em cada estudo parece determinante para os resultados dos questionários. Revelou, ainda, que há uma relação direta entre o PIB/habitante e os resultados dos questionários nas regiões com valores extremos de PIB/habitante, mas que essa relação não existe para a generalidade das regiões.