Reliability analysis is critical in measuring the effectiveness and detecting the weakness or mode of failure of other systems in various sectors such as engineering, healthcare, and social science. Stress-strength reliability is the measure of the reliability of a component; that is, the likelihood of a given strength being more significant than the applied stress so that the component will perform the intended function satisfactorily. In the present paper, we are concerned with the estimation of stress-strength reliability R=P[Y<X<Z] where X, Y, and Z are independent random variables, with X being the strength of the component and Y, Z being the stress variables. We consider that the underlying random variables have the LMP, which includes exponential and geometric distributions used in reliability analysis because of constant hazard rates. However, progressive Type-II censoring, which is common in life data studies, makes an estimation of R=P[Y<X<Z] cumbersome because data are observed on a progressive basis as units are progressively removed from a study after failure. To overcome these challenges, we have introduced the methods of shrinkage estimation and maximum penalized likelihood estimation (MPLE). The latter adds a penalty term into the likelihood function, improving the estimates, especially if there is missing or censored data. To compare the performance of the proposed estimators, we perform an extensive simulation study and compute Average Estimate (AE), Mean Square Error (MSE), Relative Absolute Bias (RAB), as well as Relative Efficiency (RE). These results come as evidence that shows the usefulness of these methods in cases with specific needs for accurate quantification of uncertainty and prediction. The results benefit particular application domains, namely cryptography, random number generators or defense methods. This work extends previous investigations in stress-strength reliability assessment, which have been conducted, among others, by Tong (1974, 1975), Johnson (1975), Bai and Hong (1992), Jeevanand and Nair (1994), Krishnamoorthy et al. (2007). Thus, this paper is built around an original line of thought by presenting the shrinkage and penalized estimations for R=P[Y<X<Z] within increasingly Type-II censoring. This research is valuable for enhancing system reliability estimation based on stochastically incomplete data and censoring.