1 May 2019 in Landscape and Urban Planning
11 January 2024 in Citizen Science: Theory and Practice
Scientific research is not value-neutral but builds on the stated and unstated values of those leading the research, influencing the choice of study topics; decisions about methods, judgments, or inferences with data; and considerations of the consequences of errors. In some fields, researchers create a positionality statement to disclose bias as a way to manage or neutralize the influence of values. Positionality refers to the way in which an individual’s worldview, and thus perceptions and research activities, is shaped by the frameworks, social identities, lived experiences, and sociopolitical context within which they live. Thinking about positionality is a valuable, yet missing, element for practitioners of participatory sciences. In this essay, we suggest that those leading participatory science projects explore their positionality, irrespective of whether or not they choose to disclose it, in order to manage values for several goals: research integrity, ethical data practices, and equity and inclusion. By reviewing and synthesizing literature, we created a tool to help leaders of participatory science projects think reflectively (for awareness of their identities and characteristics) and reflexively (from an external position for critical observation of themselves) to recognize their influence on project design and implementation. We view examining positionality as a precursor to anticipating and taking actions to minimize epistemic injustices and ultimately enhance the unique capacity of each project to advance equity, inclusion, and scientific productivity.
1 December 2022 in Environmental Justice
Geographic information system tools analyze the environmental hazards and injustice throughout the United States. This article highlights the updated Maryland Environmental Justice Screening Tool (MD EJSCREEN v2.0), a state-specific resource for visualizing local environmental justice and health disparities in Maryland. Four new functions for screening and visualizing environmental justice indicators are described and demonstrated: the Select Feature and EJScreenChart, Side-by-Side Mapper, Report Tool, and Base Map Selector. The article identifies and compares census tracts in Maryland with highest and lowest Maryland Environmental Justice Scores (MD EJScores): Johnston Square, Baltimore, Maryland, and Churchville, Maryland, respectively. This article also characterizes the spread of MD EJScores across Maryland's 1384 census tracts. The case study results indicate that, while the median MD EJScore across the state is 0.30, several of Maryland's communities of color and low-wealth communities are disproportionately and highly impacted by high exposure to air pollution, close proximity to hazardous facilities, and high rates poor health outcomes—especially in the 90th percentile of MD EJScores, which can be as much as three times the statewide median. The tool can be used by local policymakers, regulators, and community leaders in a decision-support capacity to inform strategies for reducing environmental injustice.
1 December 2022 in Environmental Justice
In 2008, the Maryland Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) developed the Maryland Park Equity Assessment Tool to visualize the socioenvironmental distribution of parks across the state and assess where resource investments would most enhance residents' access to green space. This tool, the first of its kind in Maryland (MD), represents an important advancement in environmental justice (EJ) decision making. In 2018, MDNR partnered with the authors to update the tool's rudimentary model for identifying communities with low park equity and to improve the tool's overall function and design. The updated tool scores census block groups (CBGs) in MD based on the following nine factors: population density, concentration of households <185% of the federal poverty line, concentration of children under the age of 18 years, concentration of adults 65+, concentration of non-White households, distance to public park space, distance to public transportation, and walkability, and linguistic isolation. This article provides details and rationale regarding the indicators and formula used to assign park equity scores to each CBG. The details of added user-driven functions are also described. Finally, we demonstrate the tool's utility for regional planning and decision support with a case study in a suburban EJ community. The tool can be accessed at https://dnr.maryland.gov/Pages/ParkEquity.aspx .