1 June 2024 in JCO Precision Oncology
PURPOSE: Simultaneous profiling of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) methylation and fragmentation features to improve the performance of cfDNA-based cancer detection is technically challenging. We developed a method to comprehensively analyze multimodal cfDNA genomic features for more sensitive esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) detection. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Enzymatic conversion–mediated whole-methylome sequencing was applied to plasma cfDNA samples extracted from 168 patients with ESCC and 251 noncancer controls. ESCC characteristic cfDNA methylation, fragmentation, and copy number signatures were analyzed both across the genome and at accessible cis-regulatory DNA elements. To distinguish ESCC from noncancer samples, a first-layer classifier was developed for each feature type, the prediction results of which were incorporated to construct the second-layer ensemble model. RESULTS: ESCC plasma genome displayed global hypomethylation, altered fragmentation size, and chromosomal copy number alteration. Methylation and fragmentation changes at cancer tissue–specific accessible cis-regulatory DNA elements were also observed in ESCC plasma. By integrating multimodal genomic features for ESCC detection, the ensemble model showed improved performance over individual modalities. In the training cohort with a specificity of 99.2%, the detection sensitivity was 81.0% for all stages and 70.0% for stage 0-II. Consistent performance was observed in the test cohort with a specificity of 98.4%, an all-stage sensitivity of 79.8%, and a stage 0-II sensitivity of 69.0%. The performance of the classifier was associated with the disease stage, irrespective of clinical covariates. CONCLUSION: This study comprehensively profiles the epigenomic landscape of ESCC plasma and provides a novel noninvasive and sensitive ESCC detection approach with genome-scale multimodal analysis.
20 September 2023 in JMIR Research Protocols
Background: Commonly used noninvasive serological indicators serve as a step before endoscope diagnosis and help identify the high-risk gastric cancer (GC) population. However, they are associated with high false positives and high false negatives. Alternative noninvasive approaches, such as cancer-related features in cell-free DNA (cfDNA) fragments, have been gradually identified and play essential roles in early cancer detection. The integrated analysis of multiple cfDNA features has enhanced detection sensitivity compared to individual features. Objective: This study aimed to develop and validate an assay based on assessing genomic-scale methylation and fragmentation profiles of plasma cfDNA for early cancer detection, thereby facilitating the early diagnosis of GC. The primary objective is to evaluate the overall specificity and sensitivity of the assay in predicting GC within the entire cohort, and subsequently within each clinical stage of GC. The secondary objective involved investigating the specificity and sensitivity of the assay in combination with possible serological indicators. Methods: This is an observational case-control study. Blood samples will be prospectively collected before gastroscopy from 180 patients with GC and 180 nonmalignant control subjects (healthy or with benign gastric diseases). Cases and controls will be randomly divided into a training and a testing data set at a ratio of 2:1. Plasma cfDNA will be isolated and extracted, followed by bisulfite-free low-depth whole methylome sequencing. A multidimensional model named Thorough Epigenetic Marker Integration Solution (THEMIS) will be constructed in the training data set. The model includes features such as the methylated fragment ratio, chromosomal aneuploidy of featured fragments, fragment size index, and fragment end motif. The performance of the model in distinguishing between patients with cancer and noncancer controls will then be evaluated in the testing data set. Furthermore, GC-related biomarkers, such as pepsinogen, gastrin-17, and Helicobacter pylori, will be measured for each patient, and their predictive accuracy will be assessed both independently and in combination with the THEMIS model Results: Recruitment began in November 2022 and will be ended in April 2024. As of August 2022,250 patients have been enrolled. The final data analysis is anticipated to be completed by September 2024. Conclusions: This is the first registered case-control study designed to investigate a stacked ensemble model integrating several cfDNA features generated from a bisulfite-free whole methylome sequencing assay. These features include methylation patterns, fragmentation profiles, and chromosomal copy number changes, with the aim of identifying the GC population. This study will determine whether multidimensional analysis of cfDNA will prove to be an effective strategy for distinguishing patients with GC from nonmalignant individuals within the Chinese population. We anticipate the THEMIS model will complement the standard-of-care screening and aid in identifying high-risk patients for further diagnosis. Trial Registration: ClinicalTrial.gov NCT05668910; https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05668910
17 April 2023 in JMIR Preprints
BACKGROUND Commonly used noninvasive serological indicators serve as a step before endoscope diagnosis and help identify the high-risk gastric cancer (GC) population. However, they are associated with high false positives and high false negatives. Alternative noninvasive approaches, such as cancer-related features in cell-free DNA (cfDNA) fragments, have been gradually identified and play essential roles in early cancer detection. The integrated analysis of multiple cfDNA features has enhanced detection sensitivity compared to individual features. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to develop and validate an assay based on assessing genomic-scale methylation and fragmentation profiles of plasma cfDNA for early cancer detection, thereby facilitating the early diagnosis of GC. The primary objective is to evaluate the overall specificity and sensitivity of the assay in predicting GC within the entire cohort, and subsequently within each clinical stage of GC. The secondary objective involved investigating the specificity and sensitivity of the assay in combination with possible serological indicators. METHODS This is an observational case-control study. Blood samples will be prospectively collected before gastroscopy from 180 patients with GC and 180 nonmalignant control subjects (healthy or with benign gastric diseases). Cases and controls will be randomly divided into a training and a testing data set at a ratio of 2:1. Plasma cfDNA will be isolated and extracted, followed by bisulfite-free low-depth whole methylome sequencing. A multidimensional model named Thorough Epigenetic Marker Integration Solution (THEMIS) will be constructed in the training data set. The model includes features such as the methylated fragment ratio, chromosomal aneuploidy of featured fragments, fragment size index, and fragment end motif. The performance of the model in distinguishing between patients with cancer and noncancer controls will then be evaluated in the testing data set. Furthermore, GC-related biomarkers, such as pepsinogen, gastrin-17, and Helicobacter pylori, will be measured for each patient, and their predictive accuracy will be assessed both independently and in combination with the THEMIS model RESULTS Recruitment began in November 2022 and will be ended in April 2024. As of August 2022,250 patients have been enrolled. The final data analysis is anticipated to be completed by September 2024. CONCLUSIONS This is the first registered case-control study designed to investigate a stacked ensemble model integrating several cfDNA features generated from a bisulfite-free whole methylome sequencing assay. These features include methylation patterns, fragmentation profiles, and chromosomal copy number changes, with the aim of identifying the GC population. This study will determine whether multidimensional analysis of cfDNA will prove to be an effective strategy for distinguishing patients with GC from nonmalignant individuals within the Chinese population. We anticipate the THEMIS model will complement the standard-of-care screening and aid in identifying high-risk patients for further diagnosis. CLINICALTRIAL ClinicalTrial.gov NCT05668910; https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05668910 INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT DERR1-10.2196/48247