Why oil and water do not mix: It is well known that oil forms stable droplets that carry a negative electrophoretic mobility (and negative charge) upon dispersing in water. However, the underlying mechanism is a long-debated topic. Using vibrational sum-frequency scattering spectroscopy, Pullanchery et al . recorded the interfacial vibrational spectrum in the oxygen–deuterium and carbon–hydrogen stretching regions of a hexadecane–water interface. Their spectral analysis accompanied by molecular dynamics simulations showed that water molecules form “improper” interfacial hydrogen bonds with alkyl hydrogens, resulting in the water-to-oil charge transfer that stabilizes oil droplets. This work demonstrates that sum-frequency scattering spectroscopy is a powerful technique that can improve our understanding of hydrophobicity in water-mediated chemical and biological systems. —YS