In this study, we examine how multiple and sometimes conflicting goals are prioritized and pursued in organizations. Theories of coalitions and political behavior address prioritization among goals and changes in goal emphasis over time but cannot accurately predict the behavior of organizations that pursue conflicting goals. By linking theories of performance feedback theory and variable risk preferences, we show that performance shortfalls relative to aspirations on multiple goals can trigger managerial concerns for organizational failure. In such situations, the goal perceived as more important for survival gets priority and triggers stronger reactions. Empirically, we examine how airlines’ dual focus on safety and profitability affects decisions regarding fleet changes. In the airline industry, safety and profitability have clear conflicts (at least in the short term) owing to the costs of replacing aircraft models with poor safety records. We find evidence that airlines pursue fleet safety goals, but the nature and extent of that pursuit depend on whether the firm’s profitability goals are being met. As predicted, the responsiveness to safety goals is strengthened by low profitability because safety is associated more closely with survival. The study augments existing research on multiple goals by emphasizing the nature of goal interdependencies and its implications for behavior in organizations.
In this study, we examine how the prior experiences of decision makers systematically influence their assessment of and responses to negative performance feedback. We posit that, although greater and more specialized experiences enable managers to build relevant knowledge and expertise in specific domains, they also make them overconfident in their abilities and strategies. Such experience-induced overconfidence further leads to distortions in the performance assessment process, hindering a firm’s ability to recognize and respond to poor performance. We empirically test these arguments in the context of U.S. mutual fund managers making investment decisions in response to fund performance below aspirations. As hypothesized, we find that more experienced and more specialized fund managers change their investment decisions less when faced with negative performance feedback than managers who are less experienced and less specialized. In additional analyses, we further show that the lower responsiveness of more experienced (specialized) managers is associated with the fund’s lower future performance, supporting our proposed theoretical mechanism (overconfidence). This study augments existing performance feedback research by showing how decision makers’ prior experience can impede problem-solving behavior in organizations. It also contributes to the literature on human capital and organizational learning by documenting an unintended consequence of accumulated human capital on firm adaptive behavior. Funding: This work was supported by INSEAD research & development funds. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2022.1605 .
How does generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) reshape the skills that organizations seek as they adapt to a new general-purpose technology? GenAI effectively retrieves data, performs analysis, and conveys information, so it can substitute for workers doing these activities and complement workers relying on them. A natural consequence is skill deprioritization, a systematic reduction in firms’ demand for human skills that GenAI can effectively address as organizations adjust the division of labor and integration of effort. We draw on a theoretically grounded classification of organizing skills—task division, task allocation, information provision, reward distribution, and exception management—and a queuing theory model of organizing efficiency to predict which skills firms will deprioritize first. Using a quasiexperimental design that leverages the introduction of ChatGPT as an exogenous shock, we analyze 1,820 publicly listed U.S. companies and track changes in their hiring demand patterns over a period of a ±12-month window surrounds the shock. We find significant declines in demand for monitoring (reward distribution), operational exceptions, and task division skills, with information provision also showing declines. Task allocation and conflict resolution showed greater stability, suggesting greater reliance on human judgment. These effects intensify following GPT-4’s release, indicating that capability improvements also drive adaptation. Our findings demonstrate that firms engage in immediate and selective skill deprioritization, raising questions about longer-term hollowing out of human expertise in automated domains. We contribute a novel taxonomy of organizing skills, extend queuing theory to the GenAI context, and provide early empirical evidence on how GenAI is reshaping organizational skill demands. This paper was accepted by Anita McGahan, Business Strategy. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2025.01859 .
This paper proposes that firms’ positioning in digital markets involves offering combinations of core and peripheral product functions that add value to customers. When new entrants face demand uncertainty and seek positions that match customer needs and preferences, they draw on external market feedback, specifically customer evaluations of other products, as an input to their positioning decisions. Using data on Photo & Video mobile applications in the Apple App Store, we theorize and show that two dimensions of external market feedback—overall customer dissatisfaction and customer evaluation heterogeneity—convey distinct information about the demand environment. These cues shape whether entrants position as generalists combining multiple functions or as specialists that concentrate on a core function, as well as the extent to which they differentiate from existing competitive products. Our results show that higher customer dissatisfaction is associated with greater focus on the core function and stronger differentiation in the peripheral functions. On the other hand, higher customer evaluation heterogeneity is associated with reduced focus on the core function and greater imitation in peripheral functions. This study contributes to the emerging literature on firm strategies in digital markets by identifying external market feedback as a key driver of product variety and positioning. It also advances a demand-side view of market entry by demonstrating how entrants use broad market signals to manage demand uncertainty when choosing their initial positions. Funding: This work was supported by the INSEAD [Research & Development Funds] and the Strategic Management Society [SRF Dissertation Research Grant 2018]. Supplemental Material: The online appendices are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2022.17112 .