Attached algae play a minor role in conceptual and empirical models of lake ecosystem function but paradoxically form the energetic base of food webs that support a wide variety of fishes. To explore the apparent mismatch between perceived limits on contributions of periphyton to whole‐lake primary production and its importance to consumers, we modeled the contribution of periphyton to whole‐ecosystem primary production across lake size, shape, and nutrient gradients. The distribution of available benthic habitat for periphyton is influenced by the ratio of mean depth to maximum depth (DR = 𝑧^/zmax). We modeled total phytoplankton production from water‐column nutrient availability, 𝑧^, and light. Periphyton production was a function of light‐saturated photosynthesis (BPmax) and light availability at depth. The model demonstrated that depth ratio (DR) and light attenuation strongly determined the maximum possible contribution of benthic algae to lake production, and the benthic proportion of whole‐lake primary production (BPf) declined with increasing nutrients. Shallow lakes (𝑧^ ≤ 5 m) were insensitive to DR and were dominated by either benthic or pelagic primary productivity depending on trophic status. Moderately deep oligotrophic lakes had substantial contributions by benthic primary productivity at low depth ratios and when maximum benthic photosynthesis was moderate or high. Extremely large, deep lakes always had low fractional contributions of benthic primary production. An analysis of the world's largest lakes showed that the shapes of natural lakes shift increasingly toward lower depth ratios with increasing depth, maximizing the potential importance of littoral primary production in large‐lake food webs. The repeatedly demonstrated importance of periphyton to lake food webs may reflect the combination of low depth ratios and high light penetration characteristic of large, oligotrophic lakes that in turn lead to substantial contributions of periphyton to autochthonous production.
Nearshore (littoral) habitats of clear lakes with high water quality are increasingly experiencing unexplained proliferations of filamentous algae that grow on submerged surfaces. These filamentous algal blooms (FABs) are sometimes associated with nutrient pollution in groundwater, but complex changes in climate, nutrient transport, lake hydrodynamics, and food web structure may also facilitate this emerging threat to clear lakes. A coordinated effort among members of the public, managers, and scientists is needed to document the occurrence of FABs, to standardize methods for measuring their severity, to adapt existing data collection networks to include nearshore habitats, and to mitigate and reverse this profound structural change in lake ecosystems. Current models of lake eutrophication do not explain this littoral greening. However, a cohesive response to it is essential for protecting some of the world's most valued lakes and the flora, fauna, and ecosystem services they sustain.
2 November 2017 in Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics
It seems improbable that a thin veneer of attached algae coating submerged surfaces in lakes and rivers could be the foundation of many freshwater food webs, but increasing evidence from chemical tracers supports this view. Attached algae grow on any submerged surface that receives enough light for photosynthesis, but animals often graze attached algae down to thin, barely perceptible biofilms. Algae in general are more nutritious and digestible than terrestrial plants or detritus, and attached algae are particularly harvestable, being concentrated on surfaces. Diatoms, a major component of attached algal assemblages, are especially nutritious and tolerant of heavy grazing. Algivores can track attached algal productivity over a range of spatial scales and consume a high proportion of new attached algal growth in high-light, low-nutrient ecosystems. The subsequent efficient conversion of the algae into consumer production in freshwater food webs can lead to low-producer, high-consumer biomass, patterns that Elton (1927) described as inverted trophic pyramids. Human perturbations of nutrient, sediment, and carbon loading into freshwaters and of thermal and hydrologic regimes can weaken consumer control of algae and promote nuisance attached algal blooms.
Our understanding of lake ecosystems has undergone a paradigm shift over the past few decades. While the classic tradition in limnology has been the study of planktonic, open-water habitats, a shift toward integrative and cross-habitat watershed and whole-lake perspectives has occurred. This change in perspective integrates the role of terrestrial organic matter and littoral/benthic productivity into a general recognition of multiple basal resources and consumer-mediated habitat coupling in lakes. In light of this evolving paradigm, we address 4 broad questions relating to the role of benthic productivity and food web pathways in lakes. Specifically we ask: (1) What is the contribution of attached algae to whole-lake primary production? (2) Are attached algae an important basal resource for consumers? (3) What are the roles of benthic habitats and resources in supporting lake biodiversity? (4) What is the role of lake benthic pathways in aquatic–terrestrial linkages? While this paper focuses on the role of benthic productivity in lake food webs, it reflects a larger movement toward a more integrated and holistic understanding of lake ecosystems. Recognizing the magnitude and implications of aquatic habitat coupling is necessary to understand and conserve these globally important ecosystems in our current era of unprecedented global environmental change.
Periphyton is a critical energy source for consumers in lakes of all sizes, but estimates of average, area‐specific littoral zone benthic primary production (LBP) have been hampered by low spatial and temporal resolution of productivity data. We analyzed the sensitivity of estimates of LBP to depth‐specific variation in photosynthesis‐irradiance (PE) parameters and temporal variation in water clarity using monitoring data from five northern temperate lakes. Maximum photosynthesis rates peaked in the upper epilimnion in all five lakes, and our best daily estimates of LBP ranged from 125 mg C m−2 d−1 to 425 mg C m−2 d−1. Nonlinear variation in maximum photosynthesis (PMAX) with depth caused overestimates in LBP by an average of 10% when mean values of PMAX were applied throughout the euphotic zone. Conversely, applying values of light levels at onset of saturation (Ek) from the upper epilimnion resulted in underestimating LBP by an average of 19% compared with the most data‐rich (optimal) calculations. Simplified approximations of bathymetry yielded underestimates or overestimates of LBP, depending on basin shape. Incorporating temporal variation in water clarity and daily solar irradiance did not substantially improve estimates of average summer LBP compared with estimates that incorporated summer average values of Kd, but this result should not be extrapolated to lakes with more variable water clarity. Estimates of average littoral zone benthic primary production can be optimized by incorporating depth‐specific variation in maximum periphyton productivity, saturation light intensity, and sediment surface area into calculations.