Demonstration lessons are used in China to provide models of quality music instruction. However, to date, no research has been done on the quality of demonstration lessons and how this relates to the improvement of school music education in China. This content analysis provides an insight into China’s music demonstration lesson implementation and its contextual adaptation for student-centered education (SCE). A total of 19 music demonstration lessons over 760 minutes have been examined, using both a systematic observational method and a qualitative thematic analysis method to look at in-class behavior and interaction. An analysis of data reveals that: (a) direct content-driven activities are still taking dominant roles in class, (b) students’ individuality is seldomly promoted, (c) activity-based lesson structures have become prevalent, and (d) sequential patterns under a behaviorist perspective still can be seen in China’s demonstration lessons. Although findings may not necessarily represent exactly what is happening in a regular school setting and it reveals a different adaptation of SCE compared to an international perspective, it serves as a starting point for understanding the official educational views of China and a different angle in perceiving the adaptation of SCE in practice under China context.
18 September 2024 in British Journal of Music Education
Teaching is a highly complex act, and learning to teach in an educational era that combines both teacher-centred and student-centred approaches presents additional challenges. Conducting demonstration lessons (DL) is one of the methods aimed at enhancing teachers’ instructional skills. This study examines the features and functions of this unique type of lesson from the perspective of music demonstration teachers in Guangdong, China. Through observation and interviews, the findings not only reveal the prevalence of DLs as performance-based lessons in Chinese teachers’ professional lives but also explore their distinctions from regular school teaching and their potential for improving teachers’ pedagogical abilities. Concerns and issues related to this type of lesson, along with possible solutions, are also discussed to provide recommendations for incorporating DLs into teacher training programmes in higher education institutions.
30 January 2025 in International Journal of Music Education
Formative assessment is essential in music education as it supports the music learning process, which relies mostly on feedback from self and others to improve performance. Despite growing interest in formative assessment across various subjects, there is a lack of empirical evidence on how it is applied specifically in music education. Given the crucial role of teachers in the effective implementation of formative assessment, this study aims to examine music teachers’ intentions and implementation of formative assessment, along with the factors influencing them, based on the Theory of Planned Behavior. A total of 671 music teachers from 29 cities/provinces of Mainland China were surveyed. The structural equation modeling results indicate that in the Chinese Mainland school music education context, a positive attitude toward formative assessment, a supportive and collaborative social environment, and strong confidence in using formative assessment enhance teachers’ intentions to adopt it. Additionally, greater confidence directly increases actual implementation. However, increased school support did not significantly impact teachers’ intentions or their implementation of formative assessment. The findings suggest that school administrators should focus on helping music teachers build confidence and fostering a collaborative, supportive culture for using formative assessment practices to improve music learning.
Formative assessment plays a crucial role in education by enabling teachers and students to gather detailed information about students’ learning progress and provide feedback to enhance learning. Despite growing interest in formative assessment across disciplines, its application and impact in higher music education remain underexplored. This scoping review addresses this gap by systematically mapping the landscape of formative assessment practices in university-level music education. Guided by a scoping review framework, 22 empirical studies published between 1976 and 2023 were analyzed. Drawing on Sternberg’s theory of musical intelligence, the review identifies three primary formative assessment strategies—teacher-directed, peer assessment, and self-assessment—which respectively contribute to the development of students’ creative, practical, analytical, and wisdom-based skills. These skills, when integrated, support the comprehensive growth of musical intelligence. Analytical and practical skills were most frequently enhanced through formative assessment. The review also discusses several contextual and institutional challenges, including time constraints, students’ readiness for peer and self-evaluation, and teachers’ preparedness to implement formative assessment. This study contributes to the field of both educational assessment and music education and offers critical reflections and directions for using formative assessment more effectively to support students’ musical learning experiences.