This study examines the impact of risk management committee overlap (RMCO) on firm financial performance (FP), with leverage (FLEV) as moderator variable, relying on a sample of 66 non-financial listed Jordanian firms from 2017 to 2020. FP is measured using return on assets (ROA). Therefore, references to FP in this research should be interpreted as ROA. The analysis was applied using fixed-effects (FE) and feasible generalized least squares (FGLS) methods. The findings reveal that RMCO has a positive but insignificant effect on FP. However, the moderating effect of FLEV was positive and statistically significant, indicating that the impact of RMCO on FP becomes stronger within the Amman Stock Exchange’s firms at higher levels of FLEV. The findings of this research expand the knowledge on FP by emphasizing how FLEV shapes the relationship between RMCO and FP in the context of developing economy. These observations suggest that board of directors should consider financing by debt when setting up financial policies and providing strategic guidance on management’s financial decisions, as higher levels of leverage increase the effectiveness of RMCO in improving FP. The outcomes also assist investors by clarifying the influences that contribute to enhanced FP, thereby enabling them to take more efficient investing decisions.