20 December 2011 in BMC Surgery
Peritoneal dialysis (PD) is an effective treatment for end-stage renal disease. It allows patients more freedom to perform daily activities compared to haemodialysis. Key to successful PD is the presence of a well-functioning dialysis catheter. Several complications, such as in- and outflow obstruction, peritonitis, exit-site infections, leakage and migration, can lead to catheter removal and loss of peritoneal access. Currently, different surgical techniques are in practice for PD-catheter placement. The type of insertion technique used may greatly influence the occurrence of complications. In the literature, up to 35% catheter failure has been described when using the open technique and only 13% for the laparoscopic technique. However, a well-designed randomized controlled trial is lacking.
30 November 2022 in BMC Health Services Research
BGBenjamin Y. Gravesteijn
+28
Background: The burden of the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a reduction of available health care capacity for regular care. To guide prioritisation of semielective surgery in times of scarcity, we previously developed a decision model to quantify the expected health loss due to delay of surgery, in an academic hospital setting. The aim of this study is to validate our decision model in a nonacademic setting and include additional elective surgical procedures. Methods: In this study, we used the previously published three-state cohort state-transition model, to evaluate the health effects of surgery postponement for 28 surgical procedures commonly performed in nonacademic hospitals. Scientific literature and national registries yielded nearly all input parameters, except for the quality of life (QoL) estimates which were obtained from experts using the Delphi method. Two expert panels, one from a single nonacademic hospital and one from different nonacademic hospitals in the Netherlands, were invited to estimate QoL weights. We compared estimated model results (disability adjusted life years (DALY)/month of surgical delay) based on the QoL estimates from the two panels by calculating the mean difference and the correlation between the ranks of the different surgical procedures. The eventual model was based on the combined QoL estimates from both panels. Results: Pacemaker implantation was associated with the most DALY/month of surgical delay (0.054 DALY/month, 95% CI: 0.025–0.103) and hemithyreoidectomy with the least DALY/month (0.006 DALY/month, 95% CI: 0.002–0.009). The overall mean difference of QoL estimates between the two panels was 0.005 (95% CI -0.014–0.004). The correlation between ranks was 0.983 (p < 0.001). Conclusions: Our study provides an overview of incurred health loss due to surgical delay for surgeries frequently performed in nonacademic hospitals. The quality of life estimates currently used in our model are robust and validate towards a different group of experts. These results enrich our earlier published results on academic surgeries and contribute to prioritising a more complete set of surgeries.
23 September 2024 in BMJ Open
Objectives During the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare professionals were faced with prioritisation dilemmas due to limited surgical capacity. While the views of healthcare professionals on fair allocation have been given considerable attention, the views of patients have been overlooked. To address this imbalance, our study aimed to identify which ethical principles are most supported by patients regarding the fair allocation of surgical resources. Design A Q-methodology study was conducted. Participants ranked ordered 20 statements covering different viewpoints on fair allocation according to their point of view, followed by an interview. Principal component analysis followed by varimax rotation was used to identify subgroups who broadly agreed in terms of their rankings. Setting The setting of this study was in the Netherlands. Participants 16 patient representatives were purposively sampled. Results Two perspectives were identified, both of which supported utilitarianism. In perspective 1, labelled as ‘clinical needs and outcomes’, resource allocation should aim to maximise the health gains based on individual patient characteristics. In perspective 2, labelled as ‘population outcomes and contribution to society’, allocation should maximise health gains as with perspective 1, but this should also consider societal gains. Conclusions There was a broad agreement among patient representatives that utilitarianism should be the guiding ethical principle for fair allocation of scarce surgical resources. The insights gained from this study should be integrated into policymaking and prioritisation strategies in future healthcare crises.
8 November 2023 in PLOS ONE
During the COVID-19 pandemic, prioritizing certain surgical patients became inevitable due to limited surgical capacity. This study aims to identify which factors patients value in priority setting, and to evaluate their perspective on a decision model for surgical prioritization. We enacted a qualitative exploratory study and conducted semi-structured interviews with N = 15 patients. Vignettes were used as guidance. The interviews were transcribed and iteratively analyzed using thematic analysis. We unraveled three themes: 1) general attitude towards surgical prioritization: patients showed understanding for the difficult decisions to be made, but demanded greater transparency and objectivity; 2) patient-related factors that some participants considered should, or should not, influence the prioritization: age, physical functioning, cognitive functioning, behavior, waiting time, impact on survival and quality of life, emotional consequences, and resource usage; and 3) patients’ perspective on a decision model: usage of such a model for prioritization decisions is favorable if the model is simple, uses trustworthy data, and its output is supervised by physicians. The model could also be used as a communication tool to explain prioritization dilemmas to patients. Support for the various factors and use of a decision model varied among patients. Therefore, it seems unrealistic to immediately incorporate these factors in decision models. Instead, this study calls for more research to identify feasible avenues and seek consensus.
19 May 2026 in Medical Decision Making
VCValue Based Operation Room Triage Team Collaborators
Value Based Operation Room Triage Team Collaborators
+2
Objectives: To estimate the health effects of temporarily substituting surgeries with alternative treatments to inform discussions on prioritization strategies during surgical capacity constraints. Study Setting and Design: This study was conducted in the context of the Dutch health care system. We used a decision model to estimate the health effects of temporal substituting surgery with an alternative treatment option for 11 diseases. Model outcome was the number of disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) associated with the alternative treatment during the waiting period for surgery. For each “disease–surgery” combination, the alternative treatment with the lowest DALYs was labeled the “best alternative.” These “best alternatives” were ranked in descending order of DALYs, suggesting a prioritization of surgeries. Data Sources and Analytic Sample: Parameter values were obtained from registries, scientific literature, and expert consultations. Principal Findings: A total of 23 “disease–surgery–alternative treatment” combinations were evaluated. Substituting immediate pacemaker implantation with optimal medical therapy for symptomatic bradycardia results in the largest health loss per month, estimated at 0.13 DALYs (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.08 to 0.19). Replacing implantable cardioverter–defibrillator implantation with optimal medical therapy for ventricular arrhythmias results in the second-largest health loss of 0.08 DALYs per month delay (95% CI 0.05 to 0.10). In contrast, surgeries in which substitution with alternative treatments results in minimal health impact include radiation therapy instead of laser treatment for laryngeal cancer T1–2 (−0.01 DALY, 95% CI −0.02 to 0.00) and chemoradiation instead of surgical resection for laryngeal cancer T3–4 (−0.01 DALY, 95% CI −0.02 to 0.01). Conclusions: Our study facilitates the comparison of surgery and alternative treatment options across diseases and surgical disciplines and can contribute evidence-based discussions on prioritization among health care stakeholders. Highlights: This study quantifies the health impact of substituting surgery with alternative treatments across 11 diseases using disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs). Some alternative treatments resulted in minimal or no health loss, while others were associated with substantial health detriment. The findings support evidence-based prioritization of surgical care by identifying where substitution is most and least harmful to patient outcomes.