Karen Brennan

Karen Brennan

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Karen Brennan

Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

13Years (2014-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 June 2019 in Teaching and Teacher Education
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MYMaxwell M. Yurkofsky
Maxwell M. Yurkofsky
SBSarah Blum-Smith
Sarah Blum-Smith
KBKaren Brennan
Karen Brennan

12 August 2024
Verified
Conference Paper
Open access
SYStephanie Yang
Stephanie Yang
HZHanzhang Zhao
Hanzhang Zhao
YXYudian Xu
Yudian Xu
KBKaren Brennan
Karen Brennan
BSBertrand Schneider
Bertrand Schneider
Debugging is a crucial skill for programmers, yet it can be challenging for novices to learn. The introduction of large language models (LLMs) has opened up new possibilities for providing personalized debugging support to students. However, concerns have been raised about potential student over-reliance on LLM-based tools. This mixed-methods study investigates how a pedagogically-designed LLM-based chatbot supports students’ debugging efforts in an introductory programming course. We conducted interviews and debugging think-aloud tasks with 20 students at three points throughout the semester. We specifically focused on characterizing when students initiate help from the chatbot during debugging, how they engage with the chatbot’s responses, and how they describe their learning experiences with the chatbot. By analyzing data from the debugging tasks, we identified varying help-seeking behaviors and levels of engagement with the chatbot’s responses, depending on students’ familiarity with the suggested strategies. Interviews revealed that students appreciated the content and experiential knowledge provided by the chatbot, but did not view it as a primary source for learning debugging strategies. Additionally, students self-identified certain chatbot usage behaviors as negative, “non-ideal” engagement and others as positive, “learning-oriented” usage. Based on our findings, we discuss pedagogical implications and future directions for designing pedagogical chatbots to support debugging.

15 November 2024 in ACM Transactions on Computing Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SYStephanie Yang
Stephanie Yang
MBMiles Baird
Miles Baird
EOEleanor O’rOurke
Eleanor O’rOurke
KBKaren Brennan
Karen Brennan
BSBertrand Schneider
Bertrand Schneider
Students learning computer science frequently struggle with debugging errors in their code. These struggles can have significant downstream effects—negatively influencing how students assess their programming ability and contributing to their decision to drop out of CS courses. However, debugging instruction is often an overlooked topic, and instructors report feeling unaware of effective approaches to teach debugging. Within the literature, research on the topic is sporadic, and though there are rigorous and insightful studies to be found, there is a need to synthesize instructional approaches for debugging. In this article, we review research from 2010 to 2022 on debugging interventions. We summarize the common pedagogical approaches for learning and categorize how these target specific cognitive and non-cognitive debugging skills, such as self-efficacy and emotion regulation. We also present a summary of assessment methods and their outcomes in order to discuss intervention efficacy and directions for further research. Our sample displays a diverse variety of debugging interventions and pedagogical approaches, ranging from games to unplugged activities. An evaluation of article results also presents encouraging findings, revealing several interventions that improved debugging accuracy and learning. Still, we notice gaps in interventions addressing non-cognitive debugging skills and observe limited success in guiding students toward adopting systematic debugging strategies. The review concludes with a discussion of future directions and implications for researchers and instructors in the field.

25 June 2021 in Journal of the Learning Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
KBKaren Brennan
Karen Brennan
Background: A variety of self-directed opportunities to learn how to program are available to kids. But how do kids manage the motivational and cognitive challenges of creating projects? Methods: I examined this question in the context of kids working at home with the Scratch programming environment, based on thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with 30 young creators discussing their project development processes. Findings: Ten strategies were central to kids’ progress with their projects: experimenting, planning, compromising, persevering, taking a break, asking for help, studying projects, adapting projects, creating with others, and helping others learn. Drawing on structuration theory, which frames an individual’s purposeful actions as connected to the internal and external structures to which they have access, I recast these kids’ strategies as connected to three key structures—personal interests, access to others, and time—with both enabling and inhibiting effects. Contribution: This study contributes to decades-long conversations about self-directed learning, offering a new view into the relationship between structure and self-direction by applying structuration theory to informal computer science learning. It offers a set of structures to consider when designing in support of self-direction, and acknowledges the prior problem-solving strategies that learners may bring to new areas of learning.


1 January 2024 in Journal of Technology and Teacher Education
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PHPaulina Haduong
Paulina Haduong
KBKaren Brennan
Karen Brennan
Online professional learning experiences can address K¬–12 computing teachers’ need for content knowledge and professional communities. However, it can be difficult to design effective, large-scale experiences that reach broader audiences while addressing individual teachers’ professional needs. We facilitated a two-week online professional learning workshop for 292 computing teachers, to support teachers in developing fluency with computer programming and broadening teachers’ professional networks. In this mixed-methods analysis of teachers’ participation, we drew on social network analysis methods to visualize the workshop community, examining the size and shape of the network. From the network analysis, we identified the 35 most influential participants and developed individual case studies to understand where and how participants engaged with the workshop. In this article, we share four cases of teachers with varying backgrounds, to illustrate how participation varied by teacher familiarity with the programming language and the professional community. We then consider implications for professional learning facilitators, around modeling community norms, maximizing flexibility of learning goals, and supporting participant connections. This article contributes to understandings of how to design a single experience that can address a wide range of teacher needs.