This study examines the integration of an Artificial Intelligence (AI) feedback coach in a peer feedback activity. Participants provided peers with feedback on their assignments. While providing feedback, they either received real-time adaptive AI coaching (intervention group) or not (control group). Feedback comments from participants were analyzed concerning content, text complexity, and sentiment. Survey responses were coded for sentiment and themes. Results show adverse effects of the AI feedback coach. Intervention group participants’ feedback included fewer reflective questions and adhered less to criteria. They provided shorter, more complex feedback. Students indicated mixed views on the AI feedback coach, with some finding it helpful and others distracting. A notable subset of students stated overreliance on the AI coach, prioritizing its validation over their own judgment. Results suggest that AI tools need thoughtful integration, possibly with additional scaffolding to counteract overreliance and avoid negative impact on peer feedback quality and feedback experience.
6 November 2025 in Journal of Communication Management
Purpose: This study aims to examine how structured peer feedback fosters reflexive learning and supports the development of professional communication competencies in strategic communication studies. Design/methodology/approach: Using a qualitative single case study approach, the research draws on multi-year data from a postgraduate digital communication course, analyzing student reflections on a structured peer feedback teaching activity. Findings: The findings highlight the dual benefits of giving and receiving feedback, fostering critical thinking, self-assessment and feedback literacy. Students reported deeper engagement with course objectives, enhanced confidence and preparedness for collaborative professional environments. Challenges included time constraints and occasional misalignment in peer feedback. Originality/value: This study contributes to understanding peer feedback as a pedagogical tool that supports reflexive learning and fosters the development of competencies essential for communication professionals, offering insights for integrating constructivist principles in course designs.