1 October 2020 in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
Diffraction of light limits single exposure projection lithography of periodic arrays of line-space (L/S) patterns to half-pitches (hps) of . The technology factor depends on the used illumination, mask, photoresist, and on processing conditions. The introduction of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) projection lithography with a wavelength and a numerical aperture NA of 0.33 enables the printing of 20-nm hp patterns with a relaxed technology factors . Next-generation EUV systems with numerical apertures of 0.55 and more aggressive can provide sub-8-nm hp resolution.1 Comprehensive optimization of all components of the lithographic system is required to push high NA EUV lithography to its physical limits. The increased importance of stochastic effects2,3 at smaller feature sizes places further demands on scanner and mask to provide high contrast images. Diffraction of light from three-dimensional (3D) features on the mask introduces several important mask 3D effects4 – 6 that impact the quality of the imaging, especially the image contrast. This paper employs rigorous mask diffraction and imaging simulation to understand the impact of the EUV mask absorber and to identify the most appropriate optical parameters for high NA EUV imaging.
1 March 2016 in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
The mask plays a significant role as an active optical element in lithography, for both deep ultraviolet (DUV) and extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography. Mask-induced and feature-dependent shifts of the best-focus position and other aberration-like effects were reported both for DUV immersion and for EUV lithography. We employ rigorous computation of light diffraction from lithographic masks in combination with aerial image simulation to study the root causes of these effects and their dependencies from mask and optical system parameters. Special emphasis is put on the comparison of transmission masks for DUV lithography and reflective masks for EUV lithography, respectively. Several strategies to compensate the mask-induced phase effects are discussed.
1 April 2022 in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
Background: The successful introduction of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography to high volume manufacturing has increased the interest to push this technology to its ultimate limits. This will require photoresist materials, which enable a better tradeoff between resolution, linewidth roughness and sensitivity, and the adaptation of optical resolution enhancements that were originally developed for deep ultraviolet (DUV) lithography. Aim: We review published research on attenuated phase shift masks (attPSM) for EUV with special emphasis on modeling and fundamental understanding of the imaging characteristics of alternative absorber materials. The overview on previous work is intended to summarize typical observations and learning on obtained results and to serve as a reference for further research on this important topic. Review approach: The review starts with a summary of related work on attPSM for DUV lithography. It is shown that the understanding and mitigation of mask topography (or mask 3D) effects is key for the analysis and optimization of attPSM for EUV lithography. Observations from several research groups and application of dedicated modeling approaches help to understand the physical mechanisms behind observed lateral image shifts and pitch-dependent shifts of the best focus position. Results: The imaging physics of attPSM for EUV lithography differs significantly from attPSM imaging in DUV lithography. The “double diffraction” of EUV light from the absorber, the reflection characteristics of the multilayer blank, and the guidance of light through the openings in a low-refractive-index (low-n) absorber introduce important effects that need to be considered in the design and use of attPSM in EUV lithography. It is important to use the optical properties (n and k) and the thickness of the absorber as predictive design parameters of attPSM for EUV lithography (instead of phase and reflectivity). The refractive index of the absorber material is important for binary masks as well. The discussion of low-n absorbers includes both “traditional” attPSM for EUV and low reflectivity absorbers, which exploit the guidance of light inside patterned layers. Conclusions: In-depth modeling investigations of attPSM and first experiments suggest that absorbers with a refractive index around 0.9 (low-n materials) can help to push high NA EUV lithography into the low k1 regime. Comprehensive optimization of source and mask is required to exploit the advantages of low-n absorbers. Further enhancements can help to push EUV imaging to its ultimate limit.
1 August 2017 in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
Over the recent years, extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography has demonstrated the patterning of ever-shrinking feature sizes (enabling the N7 technology node and below), whereas the EUV mask has remained unaltered, using a 70-nm tantalum (Ta)-based absorber. This has led to experimentally observed mask three-dimensional (M3D) effects at the wafer level, which are induced by the interaction between the oblique incident EUV light and the patterned absorber with typical thickness values on the order of several wavelengths. We exploit the optical properties of the absorber material of the EUV mask as an M3D mitigation strategy. Using rigorous lithographic simulations, we screen potential single-element absorber materials for their optical properties and optimal thickness for minimum best focus variation through pitch at the wafer level. In addition, the M3D mitigation by absorber material is evaluated by process window comparison of foundry N5-specific logic clips. To validate the rigorous simulation predictions and test the processing feasibility of the alternative absorber materials, we have selected the candidate single elements nickel and cobalt for an experimental evaluation on wafer substrates. We present the film characterization as well as the first patterning tests of these single-element candidate absorber materials.
1 October 2021 in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
Extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUV) has become responsible for the majority of the advances in semiconductor technology toward the 10-nm technology node and beyond. Simulations play a crucial role in the advancement of EUV lithography and they are often the most efficient means of process development. However, accurate aerial image simulations of EUV lithography incur a significant computational load, which is largely attributed to the requirement of a rigorous solution of the electromagnetic fields (EMFs) with a 3D representation of the thick EUV mask.1,2 The requirement of rigorous simulations poses a hindrance to optimizations and explorations of the parameter space. A 2D representation of the mask can be utilized to drastically speed up the process while compromising accuracy using the so-called Kirchhoff approximation, which assumes the thick mask to be infinitely thin. The infinitely thin mask model has been commonly used to simulate lithographic aerial images. Nonetheless, such approximation overestimates the amount of light reaching the wafer, and it fails to represent numerous effects attributed to the 3D profile of the mask, often referred to as the mask topography effects. Furthermore, various compact mask models have been developed to increase the computational efficiency while maintaining sufficient accuracy in representing 3D mask effects, although the main assumptions of such models are invalidated at more advanced technology nodes.3 – 5 Certain 3D mask effects or mask topography effects, such as asymmetric process windows, occur in both deep UV (DUV) and EUV lithography processes. Nonetheless, 3D mask effects manifest at a greater degree as the wavelength becomes larger in comparison to the feature sizes, and smaller in comparison to the thickness of the mask’s absorber.6 The aggregation of the 3D mask effects in EUV systems due to the smaller feature sizes makes them consume a greater part of the tolerable error budget compared to the DUV 3D mask effects.
1 July 2007 in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
As smaller feature sizes and hyper-numerical apertures are approached, rigorous electromagnetic field (EMF) simulation of light diffraction from the mask predicts a more pronounced impact of the mask topography, the optical properties of the mask materials, and the polarization of the incident light on the resulting intensity and the phase of the diffracted light, and on the imaging performance of a lithographic process. This work applies rigorous EMF simulation for the exploration of several aspects of the imaging performance of different binary and 6% attenuated mask stacks at the limits of dry, water immersion, and high index or oil immersion lithography. Several consequences with respect to typical lithographic performance parameters are discussed. The described mask diffraction phenomena have a strong impact on the sensitivity of printed linewidths and process windows with respect to the illumination intensity in the preferred state (IPS) of polarization. Advanced diffraction phenomena are also shown to be important for the lithographic performance of assist features. A new metric, the so-called assist bending efficiency (ABEF), is proposed to quantify the related effects. Modifications of the phase of the diffracted light may result in placement errors and process-window deformations.