1 April 2024 in Annals of Translational Medicine
Simulated operations (SOs) are a direct application of the Integral Theory (IT) mantras, “structure and function are related” and “restore the structure and you will improve the function”. SOs performed in a clinic setting, are the most effective way possible to test the validity of the IT predictions: stress urinary incontinence (SUI) and urge are mainly caused by laxity in the vagina or its supporting ligaments. The SUI prediction of the IT is validated if a hemostat applied vaginally in the position of the midurethra to mechanically support the pubourethral ligament (PUL) immediately stops urine loss on coughing. The urge and chronic pelvic pain (CPP) predictions of the IT are similarly validated if a patient states her urge and pain symptoms are relieved by insertion of the bottom blade of a bivalve speculum which supports the uterosacral ligaments (USLs). An important use of SOs is to preoperatively assess (by the hemostat test) whether sling surgery for SUI is likely to cure the patient. Similarly, the speculum is very useful for diagnosing whether severe urge or pain symptoms in a woman with minimal prolapse are originating from weak USLs. If digital support of a cystocele relieves urge symptoms, the patient can reasonably be informed that a cystocele repair should improve the urge as well her cystocele prolapse. Used intraoperatively under spinal anesthesia, SOs can determine whether a sling is sufficiently tight to reverse the loose PUL which is causing the SUI. Approximating both cardinal ligaments (CLs) intraoperatively can result in a remarkable disappearance of a transverese defect cystocele; approximating USLs intraoperatively can give an indication of how effective a USL plication would be surgically.
1 April 2024 in Annals of Translational Medicine
Midurethral slings (MUS) have revolutionized the treatment of stress urinary incontinence (SUI). MUS operations work by creating a collagenous pubourethral ligament (PUL). Since 1996, more than 10 million operations have been performed worldwide. Early complications with the MUS included bowel perforations, massive retropubic hemorrhages, nerve injuries, even death. Though the invention of the transobturator tape (TOT) operation, and later, minislings, has eliminated many such complications, the most frequent complication, post-operative urinary retention, remains. MUS operations are unavailable in many countries because of expense. Low-cost surgical options discussed include the tension-free artisan minisling which uses a 10 cm × 1 cm tape inserted as a “U” below the urethra; 91% cure was achieved at 5.7 years in a study of 90 women, though it was accompanied by a 4.2% erosion rate. The more recent urethral ligament plication (ULP) is based on transperineal ultrasound studies which showed that the main cause of the SUI was elongation of weak PULs. This allowed the posterior pelvic muscles to open out the posterior urethral wall to cause SUI. Basic science collagen studies indicated that suturing PULs with No. 2 wide-bore polyester sutures would provide sufficient collagen to repair weakened PULs. Cure of SUI, when it occurred, was immediate. Reference to the original experimental animal studies indicated that collagen 1, the key structural support of PUL, had formed by 3 months. This is an optimistic sign for longer term cure, substantiated by very little deterioration after 3 months over a 12-month period in the first surgical trial (unpublished data). In conclusion, the ULP operation can be performed under local anesthesia/sedation. If it fulfils its promise for longer-term cure, SUI cure will be available for hundreds of millions of women in underdeveloped countries for a few dollars per case.
1 April 2024 in Annals of Translational Medicine
The main thrust of the Integral Theory Paradigm (ITP) is that inadequate ligament collagen causes pelvic organ prolapses (POP) and pelvic symptoms, a concept validated by multiple publications which cured POP and bladder/bowel/pain dysfunctions by collagen-creating slings. Sling surgery for surgical cure of these conditions was eliminated in the United States, Europe and other regulatory jurisdictions by banning all mesh products (including tapes) in about 2017. The aim of this work was to inform of the progress of a highly promising alternative method for collage creation for ligament repair: wide-bore polyester sutures accurately applied to weak ligaments. The scientific rationale for the wide-bore polyester plication method was a revisit and analysis of prior Instron testing data from a rejected polyester aortic graft from a doctoral thesis. The analysis indicated that the collagen produced by No. 2 polyester sutures would be sufficient to repair weakened pelvic ligaments. The surgical methodology consisted of application of wide-bore No. 2 or No. 3 polyester sutures to existing vaginal surgical techniques such as cardinal/uterosacral ligament (CL/USL) repair in the Fothergill operation, deep transversus perinei (DTP) ligamentous supports of the perineal body (PB) and uniquely, pubourethral ligament (PUL) repair for stress urinary incontinence (SUI). No vaginal tissue was excised. These operations are now being performed in several centres around the world. Because of this, the results detailed below are indicative only, and necessarily incomplete, as they are only from these units. Twelve month data (n=35) for SUI cure (83%) following PUL repair by the urethral ligament plication (ULP) operation has been submitted for publication; POP quantification (POPQ) points Ba, C, Bp, D were significantly improved at 6 weeks postoperative review following repair of CLs (cystocele) and USLs (uterine/apical prolapse) (n=56): deep transverse perinei ligament repair (descending perineal syndrome “DPS”) (n=4) were cured at 6–12 months review. Though numbers are few, in the context of DPS being considered incurable, these numbers are significant. Except for the ULP operation, the techniques for cystocele, uterine prolapse, perineocele were essentially evolved versions of the Fothergill and standard PB repairs without any vaginal or ligament excisions. Though promising, more extensive and longer-term results are clearly required before this wide-bore polyester ligament repair method can become mainstream.
1 April 2024 in Annals of Translational Medicine
The bladder neck area of the vagina is known as the “zone of critical elasticity” (ZCE). Adequate vaginal elasticity at ZCE is required for the oppositely-acting muscles to independently close the distal urethra and bladder neck. Scarring at ZCE “tethers” the more powerful posterior muscles to the anterior muscles and the bladder neck is forcibly pulled open, resulting in massive urine loss. This condition is known as “tethered vagina syndrome” (TVS). In developed countries, the main cause of TVS is iatrogenic. Vaginal repairs, vaginal mesh, may cause scarring at ZCE and this directly links the oppositely-acting muscle forces. Over-elevated Burch colposuspensions may stretch the ZCE to the point where its elasticity is lost so the muscles can no longer function independently. The treatment is to dissect the vagina clear of the scarring and to insert a skin graft to the bladder neck to restore ZCE elasticity. In developing countries, extensive trauma to the vagina and bladder from obstructed childbirth can cause obstetric fistulas. In up to 40–50% of these women, there is ongoing massive urine loss after the fistula has been successfully closed. Performing a prophylactical skin graft during fistula closure if there is vaginal tissue deficit is proving to be revolutionary. In women with Goh type 4 fistula (n=45), 46% were cured (full dryness) against an expected 19%. The same operation can produce equally dramatic cures in women who continue to leak urine after successful fistula repair.
1 April 2024 in Annals of Translational Medicine
Descending perineal syndrome (DPS) was described by Parks et al. as descent of the anus on straining, typically 3–4 cm below a line drawn from the coccyx to the lower end of the. DPS is associated with obstructed defecation, with increased bulging of the perineum with straining, although perineal descent can also be seen at rest. In their review, Chaudhry and Tarnay stated: “It is controversial whether surgical management is even an option for patients with DPS”. The deep transversus perinei (DTP) ligaments are the suspensory ligaments of the perineal body (PB). DTP are approximately 4 cm long. They attach behind the upper 2/3 and lower 1/3 of the descending ramus. If, at childbirth, the PB is overstretched and displaced laterally and inferiorly, the DTP lengthens. DPS is described as descent of the anus on straining, typically 3–4 cm below a line drawn from the coccyx to the lower end of the symphysis. DPS is associated with obstructed and often, assisted defecation, with increased bulging of the perineum with straining descent of the anus on straining. The surgical methodology begins as a standard PB repair which dissects the rectum from the vagina and PB and approximates the displaced components of the PB. We added an additional step: identifying the DTPs, shortening and reinforcing them with the Tissue Fixation System (TFS) minisling or No. 2 polyester sutures. High cure rates for obstructed defecation were achieved with the TFS minisling, and initial results using No. 2 polyester sutures are favourable. The key messages from both operations is DPS is caused by stretching and elongation of DPS ligaments, and these are surgically repairable.