Japan has long faced energy insecurity due to its extreme dependence on energy imports. Why, then, has Japan failed to exploit its huge domestic geothermal energy resources, which could provide up to 10% of the country’s electricity needs? This article argues that local interests empowered by national policy have been the main obstacle to expansion of geothermal power production in Japan since the 1970s. The article substantiates its claim with a historical analysis of national geothermal policy and a fieldwork-based case study of geothermal power development in Yuzawa City, Akita Prefecture.
Geothermal energy is an important resource in the fight against climate change, but local siting issues often stand in the way. We analyze the socioeconomic determinants of the location of all geothermal drilling explorations in Japan from 1975 to 2014. Statistical analysis based on an original dataset shows that (1) municipalities with more hot springs inns than other municipalities are less likely to have a geothermal exploration, and (2) municipalities become more likely to have a geothermal exploration as their farming sector employment declines over time. We complement the statistical analysis with a qualitative case study of the politics of geothermal drilling in one Japanese hot springs town, showing how personal relationships on the local level can widen or narrow the structural ‘green versus green’ divide between hot springs inns and geothermal interests.
This introductory article to the symposium first presents and then critiques the protean power concept of the Katzenstein and Seybert volume. Although the volume underestimates the value of rational choice models to explain some cases of protean power, it rightly demonstrates that our conventional theoretical toolkit insufficiently anticipates many such disruptions. Drawing on the examples of post-World War I veterans' movements and India's 1998 decision to test nuclear weapons, I argue that the protean power research agenda should focus on the reciprocal relationship between radical uncertainty and psychological and behavioral rigidity.