Governance institutions are central to development, yet foreign aid can inadvertently harm them. Definitional ambiguity in the 'ownership' agenda contributes to the challenge of remedying these problems. This paper proposes a conceptual framework which separates 'locally led' approaches into those that give local actors 'a seat at the table', and those that provide 'their own table.' As such, it concerns the locus of decision-making power by distinguishing three 'decision spaces'-local, partnership, and external-defined by which actors hold real authority over a given policy choice. Drawing on the political governance literature, the paper argues that local actors' discretion to make policy decisions is a necessary condition for accountability, legitimacy, and contestation-and that shared decision-making in partnerships does not satisfy this condition. Despite the widespread focus on partnerships as a remedy for various aid challenges, their potential impact on political governance institutions deserves closer scrutiny.
Governance institutions are central to development, yet foreign aid caninadvertently harm them. Definitional ambiguity in the 'ownership' agendacontributes to the challenge of remedying these problems. This paper proposes aconceptual framework which separates ‘locally led’ approaches into those that givelocal actors ‘a seat at the table’, and those that provide ‘their own table.’ As such,it concerns the locus of decision-making power by distinguishing three ‘decisionspaces’ — local, partnership, and external — defined by which actors hold realauthority over a given policy choice. Drawing on the political governanceliterature, the paper argues that local actors’ discretion to make policy decisionsis a necessary condition for accountability, legitimacy, and contestation – and thatshared decision-making in partnerships does not satisfy this condition. Despitethe widespread focus on partnerships as a remedy for various aid challenges, theirpotential impact on political governance institutions deserves closer scrutiny.