16 October 2024 in Studies in Social Justice
This paper applies an Intersectionality Based Policy Analysis Framework to Ontario’s current mental health plan – The Roadmap: A Plan to Build Ontario’s Mental Health and Addictions Services – in order to identify the contextual influences, underlying values and assumptions, which promote or undermine the uptake of human rights and equity as a mental health policy priority in Ontario. We found that dominant framings of the “problem” of mental health (as lack of access, coordination or integration, as a fiscal drain, as an economic burden, and as a clinical or medical problem) served to obscure and ignore the underlying social and structural conditions that impact mental health and the human rights violations that routinely occur in the context of “care.” We discuss the implications of The Roadmap ignoring social and structural determinants of health, and by way of contrast, explore how citizen engagement and activism can support rethinking mental health policy so that it is more just and equitable.
16 October 2024 in Studies in Social Justice
In British Columbia (BC), Canada, mental health reforms over the last decade have moved back and forth between calls for practices that restrict human rights and those that are rooted in equity and social justice. In this article, we explore some of these tensions and their implications for human rights and equity in mental health care by critically analyzing three policies guiding mental health reform in BC using an intersectionality-based policy framework. Specifically, we interrogate the effects of a biomedical and individualized framing of mental health and substance use. We argue that such a framing is buttressed by neoliberal ideology and lays the groundwork for public and professional acceptance of coercive practices with particular consequences for Indigenous and racialized populations. This framing is juxtaposed with a holistic wellness and trauma-informed policy framework anchored by an understanding of the impact of colonization. However, what is missing in both policy framings is a full account of the documented ongoing human rights violations experienced by many people accessing BC’s mental health system. Our analysis shows how applying an intersectionality-based policy framework allows for a deeper exploration of the complex, interlocking systems of power and oppression that give rise to these human rights violations. We conclude with a discussion of the important role that decolonizing and intersectional approaches play for capturing the complexities of systemic inequities and advancing mental healthcare that protects and promotes mental wellbeing and human rights.
16 October 2024 in Studies in Social Justice
Colonization has had extremely negative impacts on the mental health and wellness of Indigenous peoples throughout the world. In this paper we take up colonial processes as they relate to Indigenous lives and mental health in three contexts: Canada, Kenya and Australia. This work engages storytelling and the method of storywork (Archibald et al., 2019) as a way to preserve and pass on history and as a way of resisting colonial oppression. This work is grounded in an intersectional approach to social justice and decolonization (Crenshaw, 1990; Hankivsky & Cormier, 2011), and supported sharing, knowledge co-creation and joint thematic narrative analysis of Indigenous experiences of mental health and justice systems across the three contexts. Our writing team represents a collaborative process between Indigenous and non-Indigenous authors where the members of the team most impacted by colonization use stories to reflect on the impact of colonization and its specific ties to psychiatric, justice and child welfare systems. This paper is presented in three main parts beginning with “Emile’s Story,” followed by “Remembering ‘Is That You Ruthie?’” and concluding with “Navigating Kenya’s Colonial Legacy.” This work engages a process of decolonization by challenging these destructive colonial narratives through storytelling. This paper will both document and demonstrate the importance of creating space for different forms of knowledge creation within academia.