The catch efficiency of towed fishing gears is the fraction of the target species in the gear path that were caught and retained. Catch efficiency is fundamental for calculating population status required for establishing fisheries management reference points. Consequently, catch efficiency has been estimated for many commercially important scallop (Pectinid) fisheries. This article synthesizes and discusses estimates of catch efficiency of towed gears used to target scallops, the methods for estimating catch efficiency and the factors that influence these estimates. There exists considerable variation in catch efficiency estimates among studies (0.1 to 0.7), and it is important that this variation is accounted for during surveys and stock assessments to avoid erroneous advice and estimates. The high variation was driven by differences in experimental conditions, estimation methods and scallop behavior. Scallop size and substrate type were the two most common reporting categories discussed in the studies and consequently should be considered the two most important drivers of catch efficiency. Other important factors such as gear specifications, and scallop species were featured in some studies. This review will be highly useful for designing catch efficiency experiments, survey design and stock assessments by understanding, and accounting for, catch efficiency variation.
Discard mortality can represent a potentially significant source of uncertainty for both stock assessments and fishery management measures. While the family Pectinidae is considered to be robust to the capture and handling process, understanding species-specific discard mortality rates is critical to characterize both population dynamics and to develop regulatory measures to meet management objectives. The discard mortality rate for the U.S. dredge fishery of sea scallop Placopecten magellanicus was estimated empirically via a retention study aboard industry vessels under commercial conditions. Over 16,000 sea scallops were assessed via a composite index of scallop vitality that consisted of semiqualitative measures of both overt trauma (shell damage) and response to stimuli. Results indicate that overall sea scallop discard mortality was 21% and consistent with the values currently assumed in the stock assessment. Survival mixture models support the utility of a simple metric of physical trauma as an effective predictor of mortality. Exposure time was also identified as a positively correlated factor that was important in describing the discard mortality process. Application of experimental results highlight the need to consider some operational characteristics of the fishery to reduce potential discard mortality.
The Anaskid nematode, Sulcascaris sulcata has a worldwide distribution and utilizes benthic molluscs as an intermediate host with sea turtles (Chelonioidea) serving as definitive hosts. During the spring of 2015, sea scallops (Placopecten magellanicus) harvested along the mid-Atlantic Bight (MAB) presented with rust-colored lesions on the surface of the adductor muscles. Morphological and molecular investigations determined that the lesions were caused by an infection by third- and fourth-stage larval S. sulcata. Seasonal monitoring from 2015 to 2018 delineated a stable spatial distribution of infected scallops that corresponded to a large 2013 year-class of scallops and persistent utilization of this habitat by seasonally resident loggerhead turtles. Given the life cycle and etiology of S. sulcata, the risk to human health via direct infection or allergic reaction appears to be low, however, the spatiotemporal scale of nematode-infected scallops resulted in fishery-level impacts with respect to the spatial distribution of fishing effort in response to product quality and depreciation of the value of landed scallops. The long-term trajectory of the epizootic remains unclear and continued monitoring of the spatiotemporal distribution of nematode-infected scallops is warranted as S. sulcata spatial distribution is likely dependent upon sea scallop abundance, which is currently trending toward more northerly portions of the MAB.
13 February 2026 in North American Journal of Fisheries Management
Objective: A major challenge in managing wild-capture fisheries is their dependence on natural recruitment, which can be highly variable. The Atlantic sea scallop Placopecten magellanicus supports one of the most valuable fisheries in the United States, with annual exvessel values of US$360–600 million since 2010. Fishery managers utilize annual surveys to document recruitment events and rotational area management to protect juveniles from fishing pressure. Although these measures are effective, recent high-density recruitment events have prompted consideration of a broader set of management options. We propose developing decision trees to aid in the management of future high-density recruitment events. Methods: To guide decision tree development, we asked resource managers, industry advisors, and researchers to rank their concerns associated with managing high-density recruitment events, evaluate the feasibility of proposed management measures, and rank the importance of management information in their decision-making process. Results: Participants expressed high levels of trust in the results of annual population surveys used to delineate the abundance and distribution of the resource, but they were concerned about elevated fishing mortality due to poor fishing practices in high-density areas. Participant perceptions of the proposed management measures informed the development of two decision trees: (1) evaluating management options for new recruitment events and (2) evaluating management options for rotational areas that are currently closed. Conclusions: The decision trees that we developed provide a structured framework to evaluate management considerations, with the aim of streamlining the management process for future high-density recruitment events in the Atlantic sea scallop fishery.