Gap-based silvicultural systems were developed under the assumption that richness, and diversity of tree species and other biota positively respond to variation in size of harvest-created canopy gaps. However, varying gap size alone often does not meet diversity objectives and broader goals to address contemporary forest conditions. Recent research highlights the need to consider site factors and history, natural disturbance models, within-gap structure and recruitment requirements in addition to light resources for desired tree diversity. This synthesis brings together silvicultural developments and ecological literature on gap-based management, highlighting interactions with other factors such as microsite conditions, non-tree vegetation and more. We pose a revised concept for managers and researchers to use in prescriptions and studies focused on integrated overstory and understory manipulations that increase structural complexity within and around canopy openings.
Large gaps (equivalent to twice the height of the trees, 1590 m2) originating from group selection cutting in mixed tolerant hardwood eastern white pine (Pinus strobus L.) stands of Quebec were used for geostatistical analysis of the seasonal mean of daily percent photosynthetic photon flux density (%PPFD), soil temperature and moisture, regeneration density of white pine, yellow birch (Betula alleghaniensis Britt.), and paper birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.)), and growth of white pine. %PPFD, which measures the quantity of light above the shrub layer, varied according to the northsouth axis, the maximum being located in the northern portion of gaps. Surficial soil (5 cm) temperature and moisture varied according to both northsouth and eastwest axes. The southwest sector offered favourable conditions for white pine, yellow birch, and paper birch establishment, with maximum soil moisture and minimum soil temperature encountered in this position. There was no evidence of gap partitioning at the early establishment stage, although asymmetry in the microclimate was observed. However, results indicate that spatial patterns could change in the future and a partition resulting from differential survival among species could occur. Finally, results outline a possible discordance between optimal regeneration and growth niches for white pine, since planted seedlings (>1 m) had the best growth in the central and northern section of gaps.
1 February 2010 in Canadian Journal of Forest Research
We present the 6 year effects of different cutting patterns (patch-selection cutting with 20, 30, and 40 m diameter gaps, 1 ha patch clear-cut, and uncut control) and spot scarification, on seedbed coverage and regeneration dynamics in yellow birch ( Betula alleghaniensis Britton) – conifer stands in eastern Quebec, Canada. After 3 years, yellow birch had established better in cutting patterns with gaps than in the patch clear-cut and in the control, while its density was 7 times higher in scarified than in nonscarified subplots. After 6 years, scarified openings and the borders of openings had 3–5 times more seedlings >30 cm in height than nonscarified openings and the understory between the gaps. The loss of advance growth in openings was the main result for conifer species, although recruitment of new balsam fir ( Abies balsamea (L.) Mill.) seedlings was accelerated by scarification. Despite the abundance of red spruce ( Picea rubens Sarg.) seed-trees on the site, our treatment combinations failed to promote its natural regeneration. Varying gap size did not change the total density of competing vegetation but modified the composition of this shrub layer. Our 6 year results suggest that maintaining conifer species, and the mixed composition of the stands, is uncertain over the long term.