Background. Researchers and practitioners have spent decades attempting to operationalize reading disability without an official consensus. With uniform criteria to assess reading disability, we ensure that this process is standardized across person and place, enabling practitioners to appropriately intervene, and individuals to receive intervention. A unified definition for reading disability would also act to address concerns about ethnoracial disparities in identification practices. Thus, the need for a standardized operational definition persists. Methods. Reading data for 27,000 children in first grade across the state of Florida were obtained from Florida’s Progress Monitoring and Reporting Network (PMRN) maintained by the Florida Center for Reading Research. The present study evaluated six operational definitions of reading disability in terms of their potential differential identification based on students’ ethnoracial identity. Results. Data indicated that when the definition of a reading disability included the idea of “unexpected low performance” based on performance on other benchmark measures, such as vocabulary, then Black and Hispanic students were identified at a much lower rate than White or Multi-Racial students. However, if the definition only used low performance as a criterion, then the opposite was true, with White and Multi-Racial students being identified at a much lower rate than Black and Hispanic students. This phenomenon will always occur when there are group differences on the benchmark used to measure unexpectedness. Conclusions. The varying definitions of reading disability currently used within the field will continue to differentially identify individuals, particularly along ethnoracial lines. A consensus is necessary for an operational definition to ensure that those who require reading interventions receive them.
Gene–environment processes tell us how genetic predispositions and environments work together to influence children in schools. One type of gene–environment process that has been extensively studied using behavioral genetics methods is a gene-by-environment interaction. A gene-by-environment interaction shows us when the effect of your context on a phenotype differs depending on your genetic predispositions, or vice versa, when the effect of your genetic predispositions on a phenotype differs depending on your context. Developmental behavioral geneticists interested in children’s school achievement have examined many different contexts within the gene-by-environment interaction model, including contexts measured from within children’s home and school environments. However, this work has been overwhelmingly focused on WEIRD samples children, leaving us with non-inclusive scientific evidence. This can lead to detrimental outcomes when we overgeneralize this non-inclusive scientific evidence to racialized groups. We conclude with a call to include racialized children in more research samples.
In response to inadequate response to instruction in reading, interventions are often implemented to address deficiencies in component skills associated with reading performance. However, there are factors that influence how children respond to these interventions. Specifically, socioeconomic status (SES) is a well-known correlate of academic achievement, and we hypothesized that family-SES would be associated with response to reading intervention. We explored the estimated associations between SES (free and reduced lunch status) and the distribution of response to intervention (residualized gain scores on the decoding and expressive vocabulary subtests of the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement) using the quantile regression approach in a diverse sample of elementary students (N = 1,651). Results indicated that higher family-SES was more strongly associated with greater responsiveness to intervention for both the decoding and expressive vocabulary skills measured. We conclude with a call to more thoroughly consider predictors of individual differences in response to intervention.
Background: The effect of socioeconomic status (SES) on the etiology of reading attainment has been explored many times, with past work often finding that genetic influences are suppressed under conditions of socioeconomic deprivation and more fully realized under conditions of socioeconomic advantage: a gene-SES interaction. Additionally, past work has pointed towards the presence of gene-location interactions, with the relative influence of genes and environment varying across geographic regions of the same country/state. Method: This study investigates how socioeconomic status (SES) and geographical location interact to influence the genetic and environmental components of reading attainment. Utilizing data from 2,135 twin pairs in Florida, aged between 10.71-17.77 years, the study operationalized reading attainment as reading comprehension scores from a statewide test and SES as household income. We applied a spatial twin analysis procedure to investigate how twin genetic and environmental estimates vary by geographic location. We then expanded this analysis to explore how the moderating role of SES on said genetic and environmental influences also varied by geographic location. Results:. A gene-SES interaction was found, with heritability of reading being suppressed in lower (23%) versus higher SES homes (78%). The magnitude of the moderating parameters were not consistent by location however, and ranged from -0.10 to 0.10 for the moderating effect on genetic influences, and from -0.30 to 0.05 for the moderating effect on environmental influences. For smaller areas and those with less socioeconomic variability, the magnitude of the genetic moderating parameter was high, giving rise to more fully realized genetic influences on reading there. Conclusions: SES significantly influences reading variability. However, a child’s home location matters in both the overall etiology and how strongly SES moderates said etiologies. These results point towards the presence of multiple significant environmental factors that simultaneously, and inseparably, influence the underlying etiology of reading attainment.
Timely engagement in healthcare is crucial for effective management of HIV, comorbidities, and disease prevention among older people living with HIV (PLHIV). Healthcare acceptability may be especially important for older PLHIV who have experienced long-standing stigma, medical mistrust, and culturally insensitive care. This study examined healthcare acceptability and its association with delayed care among older (≥ 50 years) PLHIV and assessed whether demographic characteristics moderated this relationship. Using data from the All of Us Research Program collected between May 2017 and July 2022, we conducted a cross-sectional analysis of 920 participants across the United States. Descriptive statistics and logistic regression were used to analyze the data. Majority of the sample identified as White (47.4%), gay or lesbian (47.1%), and publicly insured (55.2%). A one-point increase in healthcare acceptability was associated with lower odds of delayed care (aOR=0.762, 95% CI [0.691, 0.838]). Compared to White participants, the association between valuing a provider with a similar background and delayed care was stronger among Black participants, with greater importance of provider similarity associated with lower odds of delayed care (aOR=0.265, 95% CI [0.096, 0.723]). Higher comorbidity was associated with greater odds of delayed care; however, these odds were lower among participants who felt they were always treated with respect (aOR=0.514, 95% CI [0.264, 0.990]). There were no significant interactions observed between healthcare acceptability and demographic characteristics. Healthcare systems should prioritize patient-centered care, an inclusive workforce, and integration of healthcare acceptability measures into quality improvement to enhance timely care and reduce disparities among older PLHIV.
2 March 2026 in Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities