Jose A. Bayona

Jose A. Bayona

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Jose A. Bayona

School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

7Years (2020-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
13 August 2024 in Reviews of Geophysics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LMLeila Mizrahi
Leila Mizrahi
IDIrina Dallo
Irina Dallo
NENicholas J. van der Elst
Nicholas J. van der Elst
Annemarie ChristophersenAnnemarie Christophersen
Annemarie Christophersen
Ilaria SpassianiIlaria Spassiani
Ilaria Spassiani
SWStefan Wiemer
Stefan Wiemer
While deterministically predicting the time and location of earthquakes remains impossible, earthquake forecasting models can provide estimates of the probabilities of earthquakes occurring within some region over time. To enable informed decision‐making of civil protection, governmental agencies, or the public, Operational Earthquake Forecasting (OEF) systems aim to provide authoritative earthquake forecasts based on current earthquake activity in near‐real time. Establishing OEF systems involves several nontrivial choices. This review captures the current state of OEF worldwide and analyzes expert recommendations on the development, testing, and communication of earthquake forecasts. An introductory summary of OEF‐related research is followed by a description of OEF systems in Italy, New Zealand, and the United States. Combined, these two parts provide an informative and transparent snapshot of today's OEF landscape. In Section 4, we analyze the results of an expert elicitation that was conducted to seek guidance for the establishment of OEF systems. The elicitation identifies consensus and dissent on OEF issues among a non‐representative group of 20 international earthquake forecasting experts. While the experts agree that communication products should be developed in collaboration with the forecast user groups, they disagree on whether forecasting models and testing methods should be user‐dependent. No recommendations of strict model requirements could be elicited, but benchmark comparisons, prospective testing, reproducibility, and transparency are encouraged. Section 5 gives an outlook on the future of OEF. Besides covering recent research on earthquake forecasting model development and testing, upcoming OEF initiatives are described in the context of the expert elicitation findings.

18 January 2022 in Geophysical Journal International
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JBJ A Bayona
J A Bayona
WSW H Savran
W H Savran
David RhoadesDavid Rhoades
David Rhoades
Maximilian WernerMaximilian Werner
Maximilian Werner
SUMMARY: The Regional Earthquake Likelihood Models (RELM) experiment, conducted within the Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability (CSEP), showed that the smoothed seismicity (HKJ) model by Helmstetter et al. was the most informative time-independent earthquake model in California during the 2006–2010 evaluation period. The diversity of competing forecast hypotheses and geophysical data sets used in RELM was suitable for combining multiple models that could provide more informative earthquake forecasts than HKJ. Thus, Rhoades et al. created multiplicative hybrid models that involve the HKJ model as a baseline and one or more conjugate models. In retrospective evaluations, some hybrid models showed significant information gains over the HKJ forecast. Here, we prospectively assess the predictive skills of 16 hybrids and 6 original RELM forecasts at a 0.05 significance level, using a suite of traditional and new CSEP tests that rely on a Poisson and a binary likelihood function. In addition, we include consistency test results at a Bonferroni-adjusted significance level of 0.025 to address the problem of multiple tests. Furthermore, we compare the performance of each forecast to that of HKJ. The evaluation data set contains 40 target events recorded within the CSEP California testing region from 2011 January 1 to 2020 December 31, including the 2016 Hawthorne earthquake swarm in southwestern Nevada and the 2019 Ridgecrest sequence. Consistency test results show that most forecasting models overestimate the number of earthquakes and struggle to explain the spatial distribution of epicenters, especially in the case of seismicity clusters. The binary likelihood function significantly reduces the sensitivity of spatial log-likelihood scores to clustering, however; most models still fail to adequately describe spatial earthquake patterns. Contrary to retrospective analyses, our prospective test results show that none of the models are significantly more informative than the HKJ benchmark forecast, which we interpret to be due to temporal instabilities in the fit that forms hybrids. These results suggest that smoothing high-resolution, small earthquake data remains a robust method for forecasting moderate-to-large earthquakes over a period of 5–15 yr in California.

27 July 2022 in Seismological Research Letters
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
WSWilliam Savran
William Savran
JBJosé A. Bayona
José A. Bayona
PIPablo Iturrieta
Pablo Iturrieta
KAKhawaja M. Asim
Khawaja M. Asim
HBHan Bao
Han Bao
Maximilian WernerMaximilian Werner
Maximilian Werner
The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability (CSEP) is an open and global community whose mission is to accelerate earthquake predictability research through rigorous testing of probabilistic earthquake forecast models and prediction algorithms. pyCSEP supports this mission by providing open-source implementations of useful tools for evaluating earthquake forecasts. pyCSEP is a Python package that contains the following modules: (1) earthquake catalog access and processing, (2) representations of probabilistic earthquake forecasts, (3) statistical tests for evaluating earthquake forecasts, and (4) visualization routines and various other utilities. Most significantly, pyCSEP contains several statistical tests needed to evaluate earthquake forecasts, which can be forecasts expressed as expected earthquake rates in space–magnitude bins or specified as large sets of simulated catalogs (which includes candidate models for governmental operational earthquake forecasting). To showcase how pyCSEP can be used to evaluate earthquake forecasts, we have provided a reproducibility package that contains all the components required to re-create the figures published in this article. We recommend that interested readers work through the reproducibility package alongside this article. By providing useful tools to earthquake forecast modelers and facilitating an open-source software community, we hope to broaden the impact of the CSEP and further promote earthquake forecasting research.

20 November 2020 in Geophysical Journal International
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JBJ A Bayona
J A Bayona
WSW Savran
W Savran
ASA Strader
A Strader
SHS Hainzl
S Hainzl
FCF Cotton
F Cotton
DSD Schorlemmer
D Schorlemmer
Global seismicity models provide scientific hypotheses about the rate, location and magnitude of future earthquakes to occur worldwide. Given the aleatory variability of earthquake activity and epistemic uncertainties in seismicity forecasting, the veracity of these hypotheses can only be confirmed or rejected after prospective forecast evaluation. In this study, we present the construction of and test results for two updated global earthquake models, aimed at providing mean estimates of shallow (d ≤ 70 km) seismicity for seismic hazard assessment. These approaches, referred to as the Tectonic Earthquake Activity Model (TEAM) and the World Hybrid Earthquake Estimates based on Likelihood scores (WHEEL) model, use the Subduction Megathrust Earthquake Rate Forecast (SMERF2), an earthquake-rate model for subduction zones constrained by geodetic strain measurements and earthquake-catalogue information. Thus, these global ensemble seismicity models capture two independent components necessary for long-term earthquake forecasting, namely interseismic crustal strain accumulation and sudden lithospheric stress release. The calibration period for TEAM and WHEEL extends from 1 January 1977 to 31 December 2013. Accordingly, we use m ≥ 5.95 earthquakes recorded during the 2014–2019 period to pseudo-prospectively evaluate the forecasting skills of these earthquake models, and statistically compare their performances to that of the Global Earthquake Activity Rate (GEAR1) model. As a result, GEAR1 and WHEEL are the most informative global seismicity models during the pseudo-prospective test period, as both rank with the highest information scores among all participant earthquake-rate forecasts. Nonetheless, further prospective evaluations are required to more accurately assess the abilities of these global ensemble seismicity models to forecast long-term earthquake activity.

24 January 2023 in Geophysical Journal International
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
AKAsim M Khawaja
Asim M Khawaja
SHSebastian Hainzl
Sebastian Hainzl
DSDanijel Schorlemmer
Danijel Schorlemmer
PIPablo Iturrieta
Pablo Iturrieta
JBJosé A Bayona
José A Bayona
WMWarner Marzocchi
Warner Marzocchi
The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability (CSEP) is an international effort to evaluate earthquake forecast models prospectively. In CSEP, one way to express earthquake forecasts is through a grid-based format: the expected number of earthquake occurrences within 0.1○ × 0.1○ spatial cells. The spatial distribution of seismicity is thereby evaluated using the Spatial test (S-test). The high-resolution grid combined with sparse and inhomogeneous earthquake distributions leads to a huge number of cells causing disparity in the number of cells and the number of earthquakes to evaluate the forecasts, thereby affecting the statistical power of the S-test. In order to explore this issue, we conducted a global earthquake forecast experiment, in which we computed the power of the S-test to reject a spatially non-informative uniform forecast model. The S-test loses its power to reject the non-informative model when the spatial resolution is so high that every earthquake of the observed catalog tends to get a separate cell. Upon analyzing the statistical power of the S-test, we found, as expected, that the statistical power of the S-test depends upon the number of earthquakes available for testing, e. g. with the conventional high-resolution grid for the global region, we would need more than 32000 earthquakes in the observed catalog for powerful testing, which would require approximately 300 years to record M ≥ 5.95. The other factor affecting the power is more interesting and new; it is related to the spatial grid representation of the forecast model. Aggregating forecasts on multi-resolution grids can significantly increase the statistical power of the S-test. Using the recently introduced Quadtree to generate data-based multi-resolution grids, we show that the S-test reaches its maximum power in this case already for as few as 8 earthquakes in the test period. Thus we recommend for future CSEP experiments the use of Quadtree-based multi-resolution grids, where available data determine the resolution.

6 December 2022 in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
KAKhawaja M. Asim
Khawaja M. Asim
DSDanijel Schorlemmer
Danijel Schorlemmer
SHSebastian Hainzl
Sebastian Hainzl
PIPablo Iturrieta
Pablo Iturrieta
WSWilliam Savran
William Savran
Maximilian WernerMaximilian Werner
Maximilian Werner
The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability (CSEP) is an international effort to evaluate probabilistic earthquake forecasting models. CSEP provides the cyberinfrastructure and testing methods needed to evaluate earthquake forecasts. The most common way to represent a probabilistic earthquake forecast involves specifying the average rate of earthquakes within discrete spatial cells, subdivided into magnitude bins. Typically, the spatial component uses a single-resolution Cartesian grid with spatial cell dimensions of 0.1° × 0.1° in latitude and longitude, leading to 6.48 million spatial cells for the global testing region. However, the quantity of data (e.g., number of earthquakes) available to generate and test a forecast model is usually several orders of magnitude less than the millions of spatial cells, leading to a huge disparity in the number of earthquakes and the number of cells in the grid. In this study, we propose the Quadtree to create multi-resolution grid, locally adjusted mirroring the available data for forecast generation and testing, thus providing a data-driven resolution of forecasts. The Quadtree is a hierarchical tree-based data structure used in combination with the Mercator projection to generate spatial grids. It is easy to implement and has numerous scientific and technological applications. To facilitate its application to end users, we integrated codes handling Quadtrees into pyCSEP, an open-source Python package containing tools for evaluating earthquake forecasts. Using a sample model, we demonstrate how forecast model generation can be improved significantly in terms of information gain if constrained on a multi-resolution grid instead of a high-resolution uniform grid. In addition, we demonstrate that multi-resolution Quadtree grids lead to reduced computational costs. Thus, we anitcipate that Quadtree grids will be useful for developing and evaluating earthquake forecasts.