Background: Despite a paucity of evidence to support a multitude of educational innovations, curricular leaders are pressured to find innovative solutions to better prepare medical students for an evolving twenty-first century health care system. As part of this effort, this study directly compared student-rated effectiveness scores of six different learning modalities. Methods: Study participants included 286 medical students enrolled in the second-year rheumatology core at a single academic medical center between 2013 and 2017. Students were surveyed at the end of the core with a 15-item questionnaire, and student perceived effectiveness of six different learning modalities were compared. Results: The modality that outperformed all others was Live Patient Encounters (LPE), with significantly higher student-rated effectiveness scores when compared to the referent modality of Problem-Based Learning (PBL). Using a 5-point Likert scale with responses ranging from “not effective” to “highly effective,” LPE received a mean effectiveness score of 4.77 followed by Augenblick (4.21), PBL (4.11), Gout Racer video game (3.49), Rheumatology Remedy e-module (3.49), and simulation knee injection (3.09). Conclusions: Technologically advanced novel learning strategies were outperformed in this study by the more traditional active learning modality of LPE. This finding highlights the importance of testing innovative learning strategies at the level of the learner. Three additional conclusions can be drawn from this result. First, conflation of technology with innovation may lead to a myopic view of educational reform. Second, human factors seem to be responsible for the success of LPE and may have far-reaching educational rewards. Third, further applications of LPE should be tested in non-rheumatologic curricula. The relevance of this study is innately tied to the humanities-based application. While a formal qualitative analysis was not performed in this study, preliminary results suggest that live, structured patient interactions in the pre-clinical years of medical education may not only promote the learning of important educational objectives but also foster professional development, empathy, reflection, leadership, agency, and interpersonal skills. This “win-win” scenario (if true) would stand out as a rarity among strategic educational initiatives.
18 September 2025 in Journal of General Internal Medicine
Diagnostic reasoning (DR) is a core clinical skill, yet its teaching remains variable. We introduce the “5L” framework as a bedside teaching scaffold that gives educators and learners a shared, stepwise set of prompts for DR during individual encounters. By asking, “What's Lethal? What's Likely? What's Logical? What's Lurking? and What's Lingering?, we use a clinical case to systematically illustrate its use in guiding probability assessment, diagnostic fit, uncertainty reduction, and shared decision‐making. This theoretically informed framework aims to standardize DR instruction and improve integration of risk, probability, illness scripts, problem representation, uncertainty, and patient values. Future work should evaluate its impact on learning and patient outcomes.
1 August 2025 in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Background Aspiring clinician educators (CEs) need formal training and community as they transition into academic roles. To address this, we launched the Health Educators and Academic Leaders (HEAL) program at our institution in 2021, integrating communities of practice (CoP) principles and innovative curricular design. Objective To report HEAL outcomes using a principles-focused program evaluation approach. Methods HEAL’s curriculum was guided by the Kern 6-step approach and incorporated seminars, reflective teaching portfolios, mentorship, video-based coaching (VBC), and the Clinician Educator Self-Assessment Toolkit (CESAT). This 2-year program centered on 3 principles: CoP; reflective practice; and use of innovative curricula, like CE milestones. From 2021 to 2023, a mixed-methods, developmental evaluation informed the iterative refinements, emphasizing evolving principles over fixed outcomes. Data were collected from trainees via de-identified surveys and focus groups. Results Postgraduate trainees from 9 disciplines joined the inaugural HEAL cohort, with a 92.9% (13 of 14) completion rate. Seventy percent of HEAL trainees in the first year (7 of 10) ranked VBC sessions as the most valuable curricular component, while 80% (8 of 10) ranked the CESAT tool as least valuable. Qualitative feedback emphasized the value of real-time, individualized feedback and challenges with milestone-based self-evaluation tools. Eighty-nine percent (8 of 9) of HEAL trainees in the second year reported improved confidence as CEs. Conclusions By centering educational strategies on principles essential to CE development, including CoP, HEAL’s developmental evaluation approach has sustained 5 years of curricular innovation and increased the confidence of CE graduates.