Aim and Objectives: The aim of this study was to explore the sources of ethical conflict and the decision‐making processes of ICU nurses and physicians during the first and subsequent waves of the COVID‐19 pandemic.Background: Depside several studies exploring ethical conflicts during COVID‐19 pandemic, few studies have explored in depth the perceptions and experiences of critical care professionals regarding these conflicts, the decision‐making process or which have analysed the complexity of actually implementing the recommendations of scientific societies and professional/healthcare institutions in interdisciplinary samples.Design: A descriptive phenomenological study.Methods: Thirty‐eight in‐depth interviews were conducted with critical care nurses and physicians from five hospitals in Spain and Italy between December 2020 and May 2021. A thematic content analysis of the interview transcripts was conducted by two researchers. Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ) were employed to ensure the quality and transparency of this study.Results: Two main themes emerged as sources of ethical conflict: the approach to end of life in exceptional circumstances and the lack of humanisation and care resources. The former comprised two subthemes: end‐of‐life care and withholding and withdrawal of life‐sustaining treatment; the latter comprised three subthemes: the impossibility of guaranteeing the same opportunities to all, fear of contagion as a barrier to taking decisions and the need to humanise care.Conclusions: Professionals sought to take their decisions in line with professional ethics and bioethical principles, but, nevertheless, they experienced moral dilemmas and moral distress when not being able to care for, or to treat, their patients as they believed fit.Relevance to Clinical Practice: Further education and training are recommended on the provision of end‐of‐life and post‐mortem care, effective communication techniques via video calls, disclosure of bad news and bioethical models for decision‐making in highly demanding situations of uncertainty, such as those experienced during the COVID‐19 pandemic.
Background: In Hospital Emergency Department and Emergency Medical Services professionals experience situations in which they face difficulties or barriers to know patient’s advance directives and implement them. Objectives: To analyse the barriers, facilitators, and ethical conflicts perceived by health professionals derived from the management of advance directives in emergency services. Research design, participants, and context: This is a qualitative phenomenological study conducted with purposive sampling including a population of nursing and medical professionals linked to Hospital Emergency Department and Emergency Medical Services. Three focus groups were formed, totalling 24 participants. We performed an inductive-type thematic discourse analysis. Ethical considerations: This study was approved by ethical committees of Ethical Commitee of Clínic Hospital (Barcelona) and Comittee of Emergency Medical Services (Barcelona). The participants received information about the purpose of the study. Patients’ anonymity and willingness to participate in the study were guaranteed. Findings: There were four types of barriers that hindered the proper management of patients’ advance directives in Hospital Emergency Department and Emergency Medical Services: personal and professional, family members, organisational and structural, and those derived from the health system. These barriers caused ethical conflicts and hindered professionals’ decision-making. Discussion: These results are in line with those of previous studies and indicate that factors such as gender, professional category, and years of experience, in addition to professionals’ beliefs and the opinions of colleagues and family members, can also influence the professionals’ final decisions. Conclusion: The different strategies described in this study can contribute to the development of health policies and action protocols to help reduce both the barriers that hinder the correct management and implementation of advance directives and the ethical conflicts generated.
Background: Implementing the routine consultation of patient advance directives in hospital emergency departments and emergency medical services has become essential, given that advance directives constitute the frame of reference for care personalisation and respect for patients’ values and preferences related to healthcare. The aim of this study was to assess the levels and relationship of knowledge and attitudes of nursing and medical professionals towards advance directives in hospital emergency departments and emergency medical services, and to determine the correlated and predictor variables of favourable attitudes towards advance directives. Methods: Observational, descriptive, and cross-sectional study. The study was conducted in the emergency department of a second-level hospital and in the emergency medical service. Data collection was performed from January 2019 to February 2020. The STROBE guidelines were followed for the preparation of the study. Results: A total of 173 healthcare professionals responded to the questionnaire. Among them, 91.3% considered that they were not sufficiently informed about advance directives, and 74% acknowledged not having incorporated them into their usual practice. Multinomial analysis indicated a statistically significant relationship between the variable emergency medical service and having more favourable attitudes towards consulting the advance directives in their practical application (OR 2.49 [95% CI 1.06–5.88]; p = 0.037) and compliance in complex scenarios (OR 3.65 [95% CI 1.58 − 8.41]; p = 0.002). Working the afternoon and night shift was a predictor variable for obtaining a higher score with respect to attitudes in complex scenarios. Conclusion: There is an association between the level of knowledge that nursing and medical professionals have about advance directives and the scores obtained on the attitude scales at the time of practical implementation and in complex scenarios. This shows that the more knowledge professionals have, the more likely they are to consult patients' advance directives and to respect their wishes and preferences for care and/or treatment.
Aims and Objectives: To determine which factors can be considered protective of ethical conflicts in intensive care unit healthcare professionals during a pandemic.Background: The COVID‐19 pandemic gave rise to new ethical concerns in relation to the management of public health and the limitations on personal freedom. Continued exposure to ethical conflict can have a range of psychological consequences.Design: A qualitative design based on phenomenological approach.Methods: A total of 38 nurses and physicians who were regular staff members of Barcelona and Milan's public tertiary university hospitals and working in intensive care units during the first wave of the COVID‐19 pandemic. Semi‐structured online in‐depth interviews were conducted. A thematic analysis was performed by two independent researchers following the seven steps of Colaizzi's methods. We adhere COREQ guidelines.Results: One theme ‘Protective factors of ethical conflict in sanitary crisis’ and four subthemes emerged from the data: (1) knowledge of the infectious disease, (2) good communication environment, (3) psychological support and (4) keeping the same work team together.Conclusions: Four elements can be considered protective factors of ethical conflict for healthcare professionals during a sanitary crisis. While some of these factors have already been described, the joint identification of this set of four factors as a single element is, in itself, novel. This should help in ensuring the right mechanisms are in place to face future pandemics and should serve to improve institutional organisation and guarantee safe and high‐quality patient care in times of healthcare crisis.Relevance to Clinical Practice: Future strategies for the prevention of ethical conflict during sanitary crises, pandemics or other catastrophes need to consider a set of four factors as a single element. These factors are the knowledge of the infectious disease, a good communication environment, psychological support and keeping the same work team together into joint consideration.
17 October 2025 in Journal of Patient-Reported Outcomes
Purpose: Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder that manifests itself through motor and non-motor symptoms, which significantly influence quality of life. We aimed to explore the experiences of patients with PD and their caregivers before, during and after receiving treatment with neuromuscular electrostimulation (NMES), and to analyse how they perceive the changes experienced, especially in relation to swallowing and speech. Methodology: A phenomenological qualitative study was conducted through 11 focus groups (FGs): 7 with patients and 4 with caregivers, held separately. Group sizes ranged from two to six participants. The decision to include small groups, including those with only two participants, was made to achieve theoretical saturation of the data. A manual inductive thematic analysis of discourse was performed, coding responses into emergent categories. Results: The study sample consisted of 38 participants: 24 patients and 14 caregivers. The results fell into two broad categories: patient experience and carer experience. In terms of patients’ experiences, the majority reported significant improvements in swallowing, salivation and, to a lesser extent, speech. Regarding caregivers, the improvements observed in patients were perceived as a relief in their daily caregiving responsibilities, facilitating meal preparation, enhancing communication, and providing greater reassurance in supporting the treatment process. Conclusion: This qualitative study provides valuable insights into NMES treatment in PD, showing improvements in areas such as swallowing, speech and saliva. By including the experiences of patients and carers, we identify critical aspects that impact on daily life that cannot be fully explored by other methods. The findings highlight the importance of a more holistic and individualised approach to treatment. It is suggested that future qualitative research should continue to explore these experiences with a view to improving rehabilitation strategies and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) for people with PD.