We theorize 5 dimensions of academic disengagement based on students’ values, motivations, study behaviors, academic interactions, and competing involvements. Using 2010 survey data from the University of California, we find support for this conceptualization. The size of disengaged populations varied between 5% and 25%, depending on the measure used. On most measures, male students, upper-division students, students with low college GPAs, and students in the humanities and social sciences were significantly more likely, net of covariates, to be among academically disengaged populations. Students with high SAT scores were also more likely to be among academically disengaged populations.
Identity theory discusses the way in which individuals maintain their self-meanings (identities) in situations through a perceptual control process. Scholars have suggested that how closely the perceptual control system monitors identity meanings may influence the identity verification process. This idea has also been discussed in control systems theory as the concept of loop gain, an indication of how closely a control system monitors a standard. Research has not yet examined how loop gain may influence the identity verification process. This study develops a measure of loop gain (tightness of the identity control system) using dispersion in identity meanings as a proxy for the tightness of an individual’s identity control system. It tests the way tightness of the control system influences emotion when a discrepancy occurs, and finds that the tightness of the control of an identity influences the intensity of negative emotion experienced after a discrepancy.
Previous research has examined individuals' relative preference for consistent and enhancing feedback by examining reactions to negative and positive feedback. Recent research shows that, in general, individuals prefer feedback that is consistent with self-views, even if feedback is negative. It is unclear, however, whether negative and positive feedback equally affect actual changes in individuals' self-views. Using insights from Identity Control Theory (Burke 1991, 1996) and a sample of newly married couples, we examine whether positive and negative feedback are equally influential in affecting change in individuals' self-views. We also examine possible change in spouses' views. Results show that when there is a discrepancy between individuals' self-views and their spouses' views, both change in ways to become more consistent with the views of the other. Moreover, individuals and spouses are as likely to adopt negative views as they are to adopt positive views, supporting self-consistency theories.
15 October 2019 in Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice
We consider features of cocurricular activities as important learning environments outside of the classroom. Using survey data from seven large public research universities we investigated 17 specific learning opportunities that occur in student clubs and organizations. We found that cocurricular learning experiences are common and that students place high levels of importance on these opportunities. We also found that women, students with high GPAs, and upper-division students were more likely to report cocurricular learning experiences.