A new species of freshwater stingray (Potamotrygoninae) is described from the Demerara River, Guyana and río Guanare, Venezuela. It is distinguished from all other regional congeneric taxa (i.e., Potamotrygon marinae, P. schroederi, P. orbignyi, P. motoro,and P. boesemani) by a combination of meristic, morphometric, and molecular evidence. Unlike P. motoro and P. boesemani, which exhibit distinct dorsal ocelli, and P. schroederi, which has numerous tan, yellow or orange rosettes on a dark background coloration, the new species Potamotrygon siponinmorok, does not have pigment organised in spots, exhibiting reticulated patterns more similar to P. marinae and P. orbignyi.However, the new speciesdiffers from these similarly patterned species (i.e., P. marinae and P. orbignyi) by having a longer tail, fewer teeth, differently shaped teeth, and contrasting lateral line morphology. Molecular analysis corroborates P. siponinmorok, as a distinct lineage within the Potamotrygon clade, and its close relationship with P. marinae from the Eastern Guianas, P. orbignyi from the Orinoco, and P. schroederi from the rio Negro. This species description highlights the importance of thorough, complementary and integrative taxonomy studies for groups with pronounced morphological variability and levels of endemism, especially from areas under threat of habitat degradation.