The major aim of the German TwinLife study is the investigation of gene-environment interplay driving educational and other inequalities across developmental trajectories from childhood to early adulthood. TwinLife encompasses an 8-year longitudinal, cross-sequential extended twin family design with data from same-sex twins of four age cohorts (5, 11, 17, and 23 years) and their parents, as well as their non-twin siblings, partners, and children, if available, altogether containing N = 4,096 families. As such, TwinLife includes unique and openly accessible data that allows, but is not limited to, genetically informative and environmentally sensitive research on sources of inequalities regarding educational attainment, school achievement, and skill development.
Although personality differences are supposed to arise from both genetic and environmental sources, neither single genes nor specific environmental factors have yet been identified to robustly explain considerable variance. Merging relevant puzzle pieces from the current state of research, this review provides new insights into genetic and environmental personality differences. First, the nature of personality is apparently polygenic and poly-environmental, with various small, rare, and interdependent genetic and environmental factors. Second, self-ratings on broad trait dimensions as the most common operationalization of personality might mask actual genetic and environmental effects. Third, genetic and environmental factors are also interwoven and interact in multiple, complex, and probably very individual ways. Future studies should address these aspects through multi-perspective approaches and multimodal designs.
To disentangle genetic and environmental contributions to individual differences, classical twin models (CTMs) are predominantly used. Prior research revealed several conditions under which CTMs spawn biased heritability and environmentality estimates, including the simultaneous relevance of nonadditive genetic and shared environmental influences, the presence of assortative mating, and passive gene-environment covariance. Nuclear twin family models (NTFMs), adding information from parents of twins, can handle these conditions. Little is known, however, on the actual impact of such conditions considering the empirical properties displayed by various personality-related phenotypes. The present study therefore investigated differences between NTFMs and CTMs in terms of error-adjusted heritability and environmentality across 93 personality-relevant constructs based on data from 636 twin pairs and 320 parents. Overall, NTFMs resulted in significantly lower heritability and higher environmentality estimates, suggesting an overall overestimation of heritability in CTMs. These trends pertained to about two-thirds of the investigated constructs, but reversely directed changes were detectable under specific conditions. We discuss the extent to which the assumptions underlying CTMs might bias conclusions regarding genetic and environmental contributions to personality differences and demonstrate benefits of NTFMs. Furthermore, we provide user tutorials for implementing CTMs and NTFMs based on the open-source and user-friendly statistical program JASP.
Self-efficacy, internal locus of control, self-esteem and emotional stability are characterized by substantial theoretical overlap and empirical associations. In previous research, these four characteristics were frequently suggested to represent a common personality construct referred to as core self-evaluations (CSE). However, neither the structure of the construct CSE has been sufficiently validated nor its genetic and environmental sources examined, so far. The current study bridges this gap. Applying multitrait-multirater analyses of 2377 self- and 1176 informant-reports, we found substantial common variance beyond self-rater specificity, item specificity and random measurement error. Furthermore, using genetically informative data from 1146 twins, we investigated common and specific genetic and environmental sources of variance in the four characteristics. Common variance was substantially attributable to additive genetic and nonshared environmental influences, which were mediated by a higher-order latent variable. The results support the validity of the construct’s hierarchical structure with a common latent core trait accounting for the covariance between the four characteristics. Beyond nonshared environmental components specific to the four characteristics, nonadditive genetic sources accounted for common variance in self-efficacy and internal locus of control, whereas specific additive genetic factors explained variance in emotional stability, implying that these characteristics also include divergently valid aspects of personality.
The German Twin Family Panel TwinLife is a nationwide longitudinal study of twins and their family members. Primarily focusing on the development of social inequalities over the life course, TwinLife has been collecting data since October 2014 starting with 4,096 twin families (
N
total = 16,951 individuals). As Germany’s largest twin study to date, TwinLife has been surveying four birth cohorts of monozygotic and dizygotic same-sex twin pairs (initially ∼5, 11, 17, and 23 years old) and their families for 11 years. Survey data have been collected through five biennial face-to-face interviews with four computer-assisted telephone interviews in the years between. In addition, saliva samples were collected before the COVID-19 pandemic (2018-2020), during the pandemic (2021), and after (2022-2024). In this Cohort Profile, we describe the curation and initial analyses of molecular genetic and epigenetic data from the two TwinLife satellite projects TwinSNPs and TECS. Together, these projects currently comprise 12,108 processed DNA samples from 6,450 participants, extracted from the first two saliva collections before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. We compared the subsamples with the overall TwinLife sample and provide an overview of derived polygenic scores (PGS), epigenetic clocks and other methylation profile scores (MPS). We found that PGS predicted sample attrition in TwinLife, with small but significant associations between higher PGS for educational attainment and continued participation. Epigenetic clocks derived from saliva were highly correlated with chronological age ( r = .71 to r = .94) and were generally more stable over time than other MPS. PGS for epigenetic clocks were associated with the respective clock only during but not before the start of the pandemic. We discuss opportunities of combining prospectively assessed molecular (epi)genetic data in within-family designs such as TwinLife and its implications and avenues for future research.
20 December 2023 in Journal of Research in Personality