The new PLOS Data Policy will require all submitting authors to include a data availability statement as of March 1, 2014. Read more about what this means and see the policy itself in this cross-PLOS Editorial from Theo Bloom and colleagues.
The availability of workflows for data publishing could have an enormous impact on researchers, research practices and publishing paradigms, as well as on funding strategies and career and research evaluations. We present the generic components of such workflows to provide a reference model for these stakeholders. The RDA-WDS Data Publishing Workflows group set out to study the current data-publishing workflow landscape across disciplines and institutions. A diverse set of workflows were examined to identify common components and standard practices, including basic self-publishing services, institutional data repositories, long-term projects, curated data repositories, and joint data journal and repository arrangements. The results of this examination have been used to derive a data-publishing reference model comprising generic components. From an assessment of the current data-publishing landscape, we highlight important gaps and challenges to consider, especially when dealing with more complex workflows and their integration into wider community frameworks. It is clear that the data-publishing landscape is varied and dynamic and that there are important gaps and challenges. The different components of a data-publishing system need to work, to the greatest extent possible, in a seamless and integrated way to support the evolution of commonly understood and utilized standards and—eventually—to increased reproducibility. We therefore advocate the implementation of existing standards for repositories and all parts of the data-publishing process, and the development of new standards where necessary. Effective and trustworthy data publishing should be embedded in documented workflows. As more research communities seek to publish the data associated with their research, they can build on one or more of the components identified in this reference model.
Academic publishing is evolving and our current system of correcting research post-publication is failing, both ideologically and practically. It does not encourage researchers to engage in necessary post-publication changes in a consistent way. Worse yet, post-publication ‘updates’ can be misconstrued as punishments or admissions of misconduct. We propose a different model that publishers of research can apply to the content they publish, ensuring that any post-publication amendments are seamless, transparent and propagated to all the countless places online where descriptions of research appear. At the center of our proposal is use of the neutral term “amendment” to describe all forms of post-publication change to an article. We lay out a straightforward and consistent process that applies to each of three types of amendment that differ only in the extent to which the study is amended: minor, major, and complete. This proposed system supports the dynamic nature of the research process itself as researchers continue to refine or extend the work, and removes the emotive climate particularly associated with retractions and corrections to published work. It allows researchers to cite and share the most up-to-date and complete versions of articles with certainty, and gives decision makers access to the most up-to-date information. Crucially, however, we do not underestimate the importance of investigations of potential misconduct. This proposal allows two interrelated processes - amendment of articles and investigation of misconduct - to be uncoupled temporally, allowing a more rapid correction of the literature at a journal while institutional investigations take place, without either having to follow the others’ timeline.