1 July 2025 in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
Objective: Learning in the clinical environment is crucial for students to enhance practical skills. However, due to the variability of clinical settings, providing consistent teaching and sufficient patient cases can be challenging. As a result, the perceived quality of rotations often varies. Previous studies have reported mixed findings on whether teaching quality or patient encounters influence students’ perceptions of rotation quality or exam performance. Additionally, previous studies have often focused on structured teaching in clinical settings. We aimed to explore how students’ evaluations of clinical teaching outside structured learning events during rotations impact the perceived achievement of learning goals. Methods: We analysed student evaluations from paediatric and gynaecology rotations at Tampere University Medical School during the 2021– 2022 academic year. Evaluations covered clinical teaching quality, opportunities to examine patients, and perform procedures. A linear regression model was used to assess the influence of these factors on the perceived achievement of learning goals, with the statement “I achieved the given learning goals” as the dependent variable. Results: A total of 140 students evaluated the paediatric and 142 the gynaecology rotations, providing 833 and 1188 evaluations, respectively. All questions received mean scores above 5 on a 7-point scale. The mean for achieving learning goals was 5.6 for paediatrics and 5.7 for gynaecology. All independent variables showed significant associations with the dependent variable, with “The use of time was meaningful” having the greatest impact. Conclusion: Students generally reported successfully achieving their learning goals in both rotations. Notably, the perceived meaningful use of time had the greatest impact on the perceived achievement of learning outcomes.
1 January 2025 in The Clinical Teacher
Introduction: Clinical‐phase learning is integral to medical education, increasingly challenged by a rising student population. Prior research has presented conflicting findings on students' preferences for following doctors at different stages of their career. Moreover, evaluations of clerkships across specialties vary significantly. This study explored medical students' perceptions about who they received the best clinical teaching from and why. Methods: A survey was conducted among 4th‐ to 6th‐year medical students at Tampere University, Finland. Information was sought from participants on aspects regarding from whom and where they believed they received the best clinical teaching: doctors' properties (age group and career stage) and setting (field of specialty and location). Open‐ended responses were analysed using inductive content analysis. Results: We obtained 262 responses, yielding an overall response rate of 62%. Predominantly, respondents favoured resident doctors (54%), young doctors aged 25–34 years (41%), university hospitals (34%) and the field of internal medicine (25%). Common reasons cited included instructors dedicating time for teaching, enthusiasm about teaching and attentiveness to students. However, over half of the themes were related to specific answer options. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that Finnish medical students most commonly prefer to receive clinical teaching from residents and young doctors. Nevertheless, exposure to doctors at their different career stages and in various settings is perceived as valuable. To enhance clinical teaching, organisations should allocate adequate time and encourage doctors to engage actively with students, understanding their individual learning needs and fostering independent participation.
18 September 2025 in Medical Teacher
A successful mentoring process and relationship require active engagement from both mentor and mentee. This study explored and evaluated the experiences, perceptions and associated factors of mentoring within postgraduate medical education from both mentors' and mentees' perspectives. The Mentors' Competence Instrument (MCI) was used to collect data in the three Wellbeing Service Counties in Finland. The cross-sectional survey yielded a total of 154 mentor and 79 mentee responses. Statistical analyses were conducted on the quantitative data, while the qualitative data were analysed using inductive content analysis. Statistically significant differences between the two groups were observed in Reflection during mentoring, Constructive feedback, and Learner-centred evaluation. The youngest mentees (under 31 years old) received the highest overall evaluations across all MCI sum variables. Areas for improvement were identified by the mentees in the structures and resourcing of mentoring, the quality of the mentoring relationship, the mentoring process, and the pedagogical competence of the mentors. Mentees tended to evaluate the mentoring they received less positively than mentors assessed their own mentoring competence. Younger mentees appeared to rate their mentoring experience more favorably than older mentees. Mentees highlighted various aspects of mentoring that could benefit from further development.
25 March 2026 in Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development
Introduction: The CanMEDS framework, originally developed for postgraduate training, has also been adopted in undergraduate medical education. Evaluating how well undergraduate training prepares graduates for clinical work is one way to assess its success. Materials and methods: This study examined how Finnish doctors perceive the correspondence between their undergraduate education and their current work, and how the teaching of CanMEDS roles and other factors are associated with these evaluations. Data came from the Finnish nationwide Physician 2023 survey (response rate 49%). Of the 4882 respondents, 1240 had graduated between 2014 and 2023 and comprised the study group. Respondents assessed satisfaction with hospital and health centre training and with the teaching of the seven CanMEDS roles. Binary logistic regression was used to examine associations with perceived correspondence between undergraduate education and current work. Results: About 45% of respondents reported that their education corresponded well to their work. Nearly 80% were satisfied with hospital training, while only slightly more than half were satisfied with health centre training. The regression model explained 30% (Nagelkerke R 2 ) of the variance in perceived correspondence, with a correct classification rate of 71%. Teaching of Medical knowledge ( OR = 3.70, 95% CI [2.35–5.84]) showed the strongest association. Communication skills, Health Advocacy, and Leadership and Management skills were not significantly associated with perceived preparedness. Conclusions: Finnish doctors’ perceptions of undergraduate education aligning with work were strongly linked to the teaching of medical knowledge and lifelong learning. Hospital training contributed more to perceived preparedness than health centre training. Several CanMEDS roles showed limited association with preparedness.