An increase in the demand for metals required for advanced and green technologies includes the six platinum group elements (Pt, Pd, Rh, Ru, Ir, and Os). In this context, deep-sea ferromanganese crusts, known to concentrate platinum group elements (PGE), are considered a potential resource for these critical elements. Here we investigate the PGE contents of phosphatized and non-phosphatized ferromanganese crusts from the Rio Grande Rise (southwest Atlantic Ocean), a large oceanic plateau with a complex geological history involving volcanism, uplift and subaerial exposure, erosion, and subsequent subsidence. Our results indicate that PGE are primarily controlled by hydrogenetic processes in non-phosphatized crusts, which display high combined element concentrations (average ~790 ng/g, maximum 928 ng/g). In contrast, phosphatized crusts are systematically lower in PGE (average ~196 ng/g, maximum 441 ng/g). This observation contrasts with global trends that often associate higher PGE contents with phosphatized crusts. The lower contents observed in the Rio Grande Rise crusts is attributed to a high abundance of carbonate material and bioclasts within phosphatized layers, which dilute the Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides, the main hosts of the PGE. The scarcity of diagenetic Mn minerals further contributes to the low PGE contents in these layers. Our results indicate that the enrichment of PGE in Rio Grande Rise ferromanganese crusts is not directly linked to phosphatization, but rather depends on the balance between hydrogenetic growth and sedimentation, post-depositional alteration, and the specific tectono-sedimentary and oceanographic conditions that controlled crust formation.