Objectives: To describe, from the perspective of patients, distinguishing features of doctors' attempts to explain the symptoms of somatisation disorders. Design: Qualitative analysis of verbatim records of interviews in which patients recounted doctors' explanations of their symptoms. Setting: Patients with persistent somatising symptoms referred from general practices in Liverpool and St Helens and Knowsley were interviewed before entry into a treatment programme. Subjects: 228 of 324 patients referred were interviewed. Initial interviews were used to develop the process and technique, and the final analysis was based on a subsample of 68 records, randomly chosen from the transcripts of 188 subjects who were interviewed subsequently. Results: Doctors' explanations were often at odds with the patients' own thinking. Analysis showed that medical explanations could be grouped into one of three categories, defined by the patients' perceptions. Most explanations were experienced as rejecting the reality of the symptoms. An intermediate category comprised explanations that were viewed as colluding, in which the doctor acquiesced with the patients' own biomedical theories. However, a few explanations were perceived by patients as tangible, exculpating, and involving. These explanations were experienced by patients as satisfying and empowering. Conclusions: Patients with somatisation disorders feel satisfied and empowered by medical explanations that are tangible, exculpating, and involving. Empowering explanations could improve these patients' wellbeing and help to reduce the high demands they make on health services.
Objective To determine how patients with breast cancer want their doctors to communicate with them. Design Qualitative study. Setting Breast unit and patients' homes. Participants 39 women with breast cancer. Main outcome measure Patients' reports of doctors' characteristics or behaviour that they valued or deprecated. Results Patients were not primarily concerned with doctors' communication skills. Instead they emphasised doctors' enduring characteristics. Specifically, they valued doctors whom they believed were technically expert, had formed individual relationships with them, and respected them. They therefore valued forms of communication that are currently not emphasised in training and research and did not intrinsically value others that are currently thought important, including provision of information and choice. Conclusions Women with breast cancer seek to regard their doctors as attachment figures who will care for them. They seek communication that does not compromise this view and that enhances confidence that they are cared for. Testing and elaborating our analysis will help to focus communication research and teaching on what patients need rather than on what professionals think they need.