Improving the odds and pace of successful biomass and waste carbon utilization technology scale-up is crucial to decarbonizing key industries such as aviation and materials within timelines required to meet global climate goals. In this perspective, we review deficiencies commonly encountered during scale-up to show that many nascent technology developers place too much focus on simply demonstrating that technologies work in progressively larger units ("profit") without expending enough up-front research effort to identify and derisk roadblocks to commercialization (collecting "information") to inform the design of these units. We combine this conclusion with economic and timeline data collected from technology scale-up and piloting operations at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) to motivate a more scientific, risk-minimized approach to biomass and waste carbon upgrading scale-up. Our proposed approach emphasizes maximizing information collection in the smallest, most agile, and least expensive experimental setups possible, emulating the mentality embraced by R&D across the petrochemical industry. Key points are supported by examples of successful and unsuccessful scale-up efforts undertaken at NREL and elsewhere. We close by showing that the U.S. national laboratory system is uniquely well equipped to serve as a hub to facilitate effective scale-up of promising biomass and waste carbon upgrading technologies.
21 October 2023 in ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering
Reducing the energy intensity of the mechanical refining-based pretreatment process for producing lignocellulosic-derived sugars without significantly affecting enzymatic hydrolysis sugar yields is challenging. This work investigated the impact of different refining conditions on energy consumption, enzymatic sugar yields, minimum sugar selling price, and environmental impacts for the conversion of corn stover to sugars. A positive proportionate correlation between specific energy consumption and enzymatic sugar yields was observed when changing the refiner plate gap was changed, which agrees with other reported works. However, the correlation between specific energy consumption and enzymatic sugar yields is not straightforward when the rotational speed and refiner plate design change. We observed that, for a corn stover material with low consistency disc refining, specific energy consumption decreased by >50% by decreasing the rotation speed without affecting enzymatic sugar yields. By changing refiner plate designs, a 45% reduction in specific energy consumption could be achieved without affecting the glucose yield, albeit still with a detrimental impact on the xylose yield. Our high-fidelity disc refining model was able to predict the energy consumption for different refiner plate geometry designs and operating conditions. Techno-economic and life-cycle analyses indicate that the plate design and operating conditions have a direct impact on overall process power consumption and sugar yields, with sugar yields strongly dictating the minimum sugar selling price, the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions, and fossil energy consumption. To minimize the environmental impact and maximize process economics, optimization of the mechanical refining process should target maintaining high sugar yields, while lowering refining energy consumption.
A simple, low energy, and productive filtration method to clarify biomass hydrolysate to enable biochemical and thermochemical pathways to biofuels and biochemicals.
6 May 2021 in ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering
Disc refining is a critical step in the deacetylation and mechanical refining (DMR) pretreatment process for the conversion of herbaceous biomass to biofuels. It is very effective in breaking down the biomass structures to increase enzyme accessibility and sugar yield. However, it is also an energy-intensive process, which consumes fossil electricity, generating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and limits its commercialization in the biorefinery industry. To the authors’ best knowledge, this work is the first to report the development of a physics-based model in predicting the refining energy consumption during the biomass disc refining process. The developed model demonstrated its capability in accurately predicting the refining energy consumption under different operation conditions. Simulations show that the net refining energy consumption, net refining energy efficiency, and specific net energy increase with the increase in rotation speed and the decrease in the refiner plate gap. A convergence trend of these attributes was also observed between larger and smaller refiner plate gaps at increasing rotation speeds. In the scaling-up of the DMR pretreatment process, this model will be a powerful tool in the refiner plate design and operation parameter optimization to reach optimum refining energy consumption to reduce biofuel production cost and GHG emissions.
Lignocellulosic biomass is a feedstock for fuels and chemicals that does not compete with food resources and has less contaminants than refuse-derived biomass feedstocks. To convert lignocellulosics to biofuels or value-added products, multiple processing steps are typically necessary. One method of producing biofuels from lignocellulosic biomass utilizes a deacetylation and mechanical refining pretreatment and an enzymatic hydrolysis reaction to produce fermentable sugars from cellulose and hemicellulose. The rheological properties of biomass, such as yield stress and plastic viscosity, change during enzymatic hydrolysis and alter the energy requirements for pumping and mixing, an important consideration for the design of processing equipment. The dynamic changes in rheological properties that occur in a corn stover feedstock undergoing enzymatic hydrolysis are characterized in this work, and the influence on pressure losses in piping systems is estimated. Two rheometer geometries were fabricated with stereolithography 3D printing to reduce wall slip and sample ejection. The slurries have complex rheological behaviors that include shear-thinning behavior. Shear stress ramps were performed on samples at 20 and 50 °C using the custom geometries, and the Herschel–Bulkley model was fit to the data. The dynamic nature of the rheological properties is correlated with changes in the average fiber length at various extents of reaction, and the influence of solids concentration on the observed rheology and piping pressure losses is discussed.