The E‐vergent Northern Apennines formed by Oligocene‐Miocene convergence and westward subduction of Adria beneath Europe. Extension ensued in the Mid‐Late Miocene reflecting lower plate roll‐back and causing opening of the back‐arc Northern Tyrrhenian Sea. Post‐orogenic extension is commonly advocated as the main driver of the exhumation of the belt's inner domain high‐pressure/low‐temperature (HP‐LT) rock units. The Acquadolce Subunit of the Eastern Elba nappe stack contains HP‐LT rocks recording peak blueschist conditions of 1.5–1.8 GPa at 320°C–370°C loosely dated to the Oligocene‐Early Miocene. It is sandwiched by two Late Miocene, out‐of‐sequence top‐to‐the E thrusts between Jurassic LP serpentinites on top and HT–LP contact metamorphosed marbles at its base. We document widespread W‐verging ductile asymmetries within the Acquadolce Subunit, which correspond to top‐to‐the W extensional shearing for the nappe stack current orientation. This allowed for early syn‐orogenic exhumation from blueschist‐ to greenschist‐facies conditions, wherein coeval W‐directed extension at the top of the exhuming units acted synchronously with E‐directed thrusting at their base causing exhumation by extrusion in an overall contractional setting. The basal, E‐vergent thrusting is, however, challenging to document as the wedge has since been reworked by Late Miocene, E‐verging compressive tectonics, contact metamorphism, and later extension, obliterating much of the evidence supporting exhumation by extrusion during the early stages of wedge build‐up. Syn‐orogenic exhumation by extrusion from deep structural levels within the orogenic wedge is a viable mechanism to account for other exhumed HP‐LT units in the inner part of the belt.
We document the tectonic and metamorphic evolution of thrust nappes of the eastern island of Elba. The area exposes a natural cross section of the Northern Apennines hinterland, from the metamorphic basement units to the overlying continent- and ocean-derived nappes. We integrated mapping, analysis of structures and microstructures, and the interpretation of drill core logs with lithostratigraphic, metamorphic, and geochronological constraints, producing a novel geological map of eastern Elba (1:5’000 scale). We show that the area experienced polyphase Oligocene – Pliocene contractional tectonics marked by in-sequence and out-of-sequence thrusting accompanied by folding and overprinted by faulting in the Pliocene. Magmatism occurred during contraction with post-magmatic thrusting ultimately coupling HP-LT and LP-HT units. Drill core logs allow for the first time the reconstruction of the N-dipping character of the Zuccale Fault, which represents the youngest (late Miocene – early Pliocene) large-scale structure in the area.