Nature conservation begins with detailed knowledge of the ecosystem based on inventories and maps. A difficult part of the conservation process subsequently starts, namely, the design of an action plan that achieves the desired protection outcome. As both funding and time are limited, conservation is subject to difficult trade-offs among competing land uses. We present a novel approach based on the Q-method to support local stakeholders that go beyond its usual use in assisting decision-making. We suggest a new usage of the Q-method: a tool to support conservation action prioritization. Our results indicate that the Q-method has valuable attributes, as (1) it encourages individual reflection on one’s own priorities; (2) it identifies different prioritization patterns among respondents; (3) it provides input to later collective discussions, ultimately contributing to establishing consensus; (4) it brings additional arguments to conservation planners based on the latter’s declared priorities. Overall, this use of Q-method can help stakeholders prioritize conservation actions, a crucial step toward achieving ecologically and socially robust conservation action plan.
22 January 2024 in Environmental Policy and Governance
By generating and explaining facts, science holds an important role in environmental policy decision‐making. However, scientific knowledge is often framed as objective and neutral in policy debates, which can be challenged by stakeholders who have a different view of the issue. To counter this situation, we propose a novel scientific approach to analyze problems that are highly contested and seem difficult to resolve, that is, wicked problems. Our study combined post‐normal science and environmental justice perspectives to shed light on a wicked problem—the largely unsuccessful efforts to rehabilitate yellow perch stocks in Lac Saint‐Pierre (LSP), Quebec, Canada. The combination of these two perspectives allows us to investigate the causes of the decrease of yellow perch stocks and the social and institutional barriers to rehabilitation—which can only be overcome if the injustice perceived by different stakeholders is overcome. Our study presents an approach that addresses uncertainties, integrates various knowledge forms, reassesses decision‐making procedures, and highlights inequalities within a specified territory. The research also underlines the importance of the qualitative dimension in the development of knowledge and the need to address equity in the development of environmental policies.
The spreading of Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis (Bti) in urban waterways, as a biological larvicide to control biting insect populations and mitigate disease transmission, has been subject to scientific scrutiny due to its potential environmental impacts. Public and political discussions have revealed recurring opinions that reflect broader social perspectives. While scientific research on Bti progresses, knowledge of public understanding and perspectives, which are important for decision-making, remains limited. The main objective of this research was to identify and compare the social perspectives of Quebec citizens, primarily in the city of Gatineau, regarding the use of Bti for mosquito and black fly control in aquatic environments. We used Q methodology, a mixed approach combining both quantitative and qualitative methods to identify social perspectives related to the use of Bti. Our analysis revealed three social perspectives, which account for 51% of the explained variance. They reflect the broader range of opinion within citizens, and are described as “The critical environmentalist”, “The diligent mosquito hunter”, and “The Bti enthusiast”. Each accounting for 29%, 12% and 10% of the explained variance, respectively. The common thread across all three perspectives is the minimal public awareness and understanding of Bti and its environmental implications. Providing a first characterization of social perspectives in North America regarding larvicides, this research contributes to a more comprehensive understanding of public opinion and informs the development of inclusive and transparent policies.
Wetlands are crucial nature-based solutions to the dual crises of climate change and biodiversity loss, and investing in their protection and restoration is central to global mitigation and adaptation strategies. However, allocating resources necessitates accounting for societal preferences, which vary by region and with individual interests and socioeconomic characteristics. We estimated the willingness-to-pay (WTP) of Quebec, Canada residents for restoring wetlands beyond the no net loss protection provided by law. We used a discrete choice experiment with 3,304 Québec residents from its 17 regions to assess their preferences and WTP for restoration outcomes in terms of varying ecosystem services and tested how region, wetland recreational use preferences, and socioeconomic characteristics influence responses. Results reveal strong overall support for wetland restoration, with the highest WTP values associated with regulating services such as biodiversity support, water quality improvement, and climate regulation. Province-wide WTP estimates range from 252 to 363 million Canadian dollars (2021) per year for restoration scenarios combining these regulating services with recreational benefits. Provisioning and cultural services preferences are influenced by respondents’ regions and wetland recreational habits. Respondents value restoration scenarios without explicit ecosystem services negatively, highlighting the importance of clearly articulated outcomes. Support is higher among younger, more educated, middle income and recreation-oriented individuals. Province-wide aggregate WTP exceeds recent wetland restoration cost estimates. Restoration efforts reflecting societal diversity and priorities can promote greater public trust, policy legitimacy, and the success of a conservation plan, especially if implemented to align with national and international biodiversity and climate commitments.