31 July 2014 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
In this study, the authors examine the hypothetical performance of various low volatility strategies in historical U.S., global developed, and emerging markets. The strategies we replicated outperformed cap-weighted market indices due to exposure to the value, BAB (betting against beta), and duration factors. (The duration factor introduced by the authors here is new to the literature.) A reduction in market beta drives the drop in volatility. The authors report that low volatility strategies can contribute to a more risk-diversified equity portfolio which earns long-term returns from multiple premium sources. The lower risk and higher return seem persistent across geographies and over time. Nonetheless, the authors identify flaws with naïve approaches to portfolio construction, which tend to result in high turnover, low liquidity, and concentrated country and industry allocations. Additionally, price increases would eliminate low volatility stocks’ performance advantage. The conclusion of the authors is ...
20 March 2019 in CFA Magazine
Although hidden, the implicit market impact costs of factor investing may substantially erode a strategy’s expected excess returns. The rebalancing data of a suite of large and long-standing factor-investing indexes are used in this study to model these market impact costs. A framework to assess the costs of rebalancing activities is introduced. These costs are then attributed to characteristics that intuitively describe the strategies’ demands on liquidity, such as rate of turnover and the concentration of turnover. A number of popular factor-investing implementations are identified, and the authors discuss how their index construction methods, when thoughtfully designed, can reduce market impact costs. Disclosure: The authors report no conflicts of interest. Editor’s Note Submitted 10 May 2018 Accepted 12 December 2018 by Stephen J. Brown
31 October 2017 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
Because of mean reversion, the Shiller cyclically adjusted price/earnings (P/E) ratio is a powerful predictor of long-horizon capital market returns. Like other valuation metrics, however, it is a poor predictor of short-term returns. The authors find that this is because the “normal” level of the Shiller P/E ratio varies with economic conditions. Other researchers have shown that while periods of moderate real interest rates allow higher market valuations, P/Es tend to fall when real rates are high or low. The present authors show a similar linkage between P/Es and inflation. Moderate, rather than rock-bottom, levels of inflation and real interest rates are associated with the highest valuation multiples, creating a valuation “mountain.” The authors also extend these findings to international developed markets. They further demonstrate that the P/E ratio becomes a statistically significant and economically meaningful predictor of shorter-term returns under the assumption that P/Es mean-revert toward the levels suggested by prevailing macroeconomic conditions rather than toward long-term averages.
26 February 2018 in The Journal of Index Investing
The authors compare the qualitative properties and the risk and return profiles of simulated multifactor portfolios constructed in accordance with two different methodologies. The first, the integrating approach, is a process that searches the universe for securities that have exposures to various target factors and selects the ones with the highest composite scores. The second, the mixing approach, achieves the desired exposure to multiple factors by allocating assets across single-factor portfolios. The authors tested portfolios designed to capture value, momentum, profitability, investment, and low-beta factor premiums. Integrating outperformed mixing absolutely and on a risk-adjusted basis. The integrating strategy, however, proved to have higher concentration and turnover, resulting in idiosyncratic active risk and estimated transaction costs that reduced its return advantage over the mixing strategy. In addition, the mixing approach offers the practical benefits of transparency, flexibility, and ease of performance attribution. These features make mixing a viable choice, especially for investors and practitioners in a principal/agent relationship.
1 November 2011 in CFA Magazine