Blockade of IFN-α but not IFN-β signaling using either an antibody or a selective S1PR1 agonist, CYM-5442, prevented type 1 diabetes (T1D) in the mouse Rip-LCMV T1D model. First, treatment with antibody or CYM-5442 limited the migration of autoimmune “antiself” T cells to the external boundaries around the islets and prevented their entry into the islets so they could not be positioned to engage, kill, and thus remove insulin-producing β cells. Second, CYM-5442 induced an exhaustion signature in antiself T cells by up-regulating the negative immune regulator receptor genes Pdcd1, Lag3, Ctla4, Tigit, and Btla, thereby limiting their killing ability. By such means, insulin production was preserved and glucose regulation maintained, and a mechanism for S1PR1 immunomodulation described. Significance Type 1 diabetes (T1D) is an increasing medical health problem caused by autoimmune T cells killing insulin-producing β cells in the islets of Langerhans. When the majority of β cells are destroyed, unless exogenous insulin is administered, ketoacidosis and death follow. However, providing exogenous insulin does not prevent the resultant complications of stroke, heart disease, visual impairment, or faulty wound healing, indicating the need to preserve β cells in the prediabetic stage to insure endogenous insulin production. We show that blockage of IFN-α signaling prior to clinical T1D disease by antibody or a sphingosine-1 receptor agonist prevents autoaggressive T cells from entering the islets and killing β cells. The result is aborting T1D by acting at the prediabetic stage.