Understanding how psychological dynamics in teams influence the effectiveness of students' teamwork behaviors improves instructors' ability to manage student teams. This research study explored the relative importance of three measures of team dynamics in predicting five behavioral dimensions of effective teamwork. Data were collected from 1780 students in a first-year engineering course in Spring 2020, and 1638 students' data remained after removing multivariate outliers. Relative weight analysis via RWA-Web was conducted for this study as it revealed the pure and independent contribution of each predictor for criterion variables. Results showed that the combination of conflict ( $\mathrm{R}2=0.00293,\ \mathrm{p} < .05$ ), cohesiveness ( $\mathrm{R}2=0.00126,\ \mathrm{p} < .05$ ), and psychological safety ( $\mathrm{R}2=0.00254,\ \mathrm{p} < .05$ ) explained 0.0067 of the variances in five teamwork behavior constructs. On the one hand, these results show that compared to psychological safety and cohesiveness, conflict was the most significant factor influencing teamwork behavioral effectiveness. On the other hand, the results also reveal that all three of these measures have extremely low predictive power. Therefore, while this work might suggest that instructors need to pay closer attention to monitor the conflict in student teams to improve their teamwork skills, the results are confounded by the low variability in ratings overall. Most teams report high ratings - a mean greater than 4 on a 5-point scale once the behavioral scale is converted to numeric values. Noting that our greatest concern lies with identifying and remediating dysfunctional teams, the RWA analysis will be repeated on a sample restricted to teams showing some evidence of dysfunction, which will be reported in the full manuscript.
28 December 2024 in European Journal of Engineering Education