16 September 2014 in Journal of Organizational Behavior
19 February 2015 in Journal of Business Ethics
1 January 2014 in Academy of Management Proceedings
Researchers have generally treated organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) as positive and counterproductive work behaviors (CWBs) as negative forms of discretionary work behavior. As a consequence, there has been an extensive focus on the symmetrical relationships surrounding these behaviors (i.e., focusing on the positive outcomes of OCBs and the negative outcomes of CWBs), to the neglect of recognizing possible asymmetric outcomes of the same behaviors. One possible reason asymmetric outcomes have been overlooked is the lack of organizational research that takes a multi- stakeholder perspective to studying these behaviors. We argue that by considering OCBs and CWBs from the perspectives of multiple stakeholders, research will be better able to identify more asymmetric outcomes of these behaviors, and thus better understand these behaviors overall. The current paper identifies asymmetric outcomes of OCBs and CWBs for multiple stakeholders and identifies conditions under which OCBs (positive) and CWBs (negative discretionary work behaviors) may be more likely to result in negative and positive outcomes, respectively.
1 January 2014 in Academy of Management Proceedings
While substantial research has examined factors that drive employees to engage in counterproductive work behaviors (CWB) (i.e., “pull factors”), little research attention has been devoted to factors that motivate employees to avoid CWB (i.e., “push factors”). The current study leveraged the Theory of Planned Behavior (Azjen, 1991) as a theoretical framework from which to study beliefs that act as deterrents to CWB in a context where employees may be motivated to enact these behaviors (operationalized here as injustice). Although participants in our qualitative study indicated potential benefits to engaging in CWB in response to injustice, they also noted beliefs that CWB may make the situation worse, harm the employee’s reputation, and harm uninvolved third parties. Further, there were also strong identity-related themes that cut across employees’ behavioral, normative, and control beliefs. We discuss practical implications for deterring CWB in organizations.