26 October 2016 in PLOS ONE
Genomic selection was recently introduced in plant breeding. The objective of this study was to develop genomic prediction for important seed quality parameters in spring barley. The aim was to predict breeding values without expensive phenotyping of large sets of lines. A total number of 309 advanced spring barley lines tested at two locations each with three replicates were phenotyped and each line was genotyped by Illumina iSelect 9Kbarley chip. The population originated from two different breeding sets, which were phenotyped in two different years. Phenotypic measurements considered were: seed size, protein content, protein yield, test weight and ergosterol content. A leave-one-out cross-validation strategy revealed high prediction accuracies ranging between 0.40 and 0.83. Prediction across breeding sets resulted in reduced accuracies compared to the leave-one-out strategy. Furthermore, predicting across full and half-sib-families resulted in reduced prediction accuracies. Additionally, predictions were performed using reduced marker sets and reduced training population sets. In conclusion, using less than 200 lines in the training set can result in low prediction accuracy, and the accuracy will then be highly dependent on the family structure of the selected training set. However, the results also indicate that relatively small training sets (200 lines) are sufficient for genomic prediction in commercial barley breeding. In addition, our results indicate a minimum marker set of 1,000 to decrease the risk of low prediction accuracy for some traits or some families.
13 June 2017 in Plant Breeding
10 August 2017 in Crop Science
Genomic prediction (GP) combines genomewide marker data with phenotypic data in a training population to predict the genomic estimated breeding values of untested individuals in a relevant testing population. Our objective was to evaluate the effects of population structure, genotype × trial, tester, and management interactions, and imputation methods on the accuracy of GP for grain yield in the CIMMYT's African maize (Zea mays L.) program. The dataset included 2022 diverse breeding lines in 156 Stage 1 yield trials and 66,000 single‐nucleotide polymorphism markers. The first two principal components from principal component analysis explained 10.5% of the variance in marker data. Based on marker data, five clusters were detected, but cluster of origin explained only 2% of the phenotypic variation. Prediction accuracy, assessed by cross validation, ranged from 0.20 to 0.36 within clusters and from 0.04 to 0.26 across clusters. Mean GP accuracy within clusters (0.27) outperformed pedigree‐based prediction (0.03). Imputation methods did not strongly affect prediction accuracy. Testers and management had large effects. To achieve acceptable GP accuracy within such a diverse population, one can employ (i) a very large training population size, (ii) carefully planned and relevant testers, and (iii) common trial environments and management between the training and validation populations and related genetic materials.
1 May 2016 in Crop Science
Until now, genomic prediction (GP) in plant breeding has only used information from individuals that have been genotyped. Information from nongenotyped relatives of genotyped individuals can also be used. Single‐step GP combines marker and pedigree information into a single relationship matrix to perform GP. The objective of this study was to evaluate single‐step GP in a wheat breeding program. We compared the performance of pedigree‐based, marker‐based, and single‐step models (ABLUP, GBLUP, and HBLUP, respectively). Data consisted of 1176 genotyped (via genotyping‐by‐sequencing) and 11,131 nongenotyped wheat lines replicated in five management environments at the CIMMYT experiment station in Obregon, Mexico. Analyses involved three scenarios: (i) all lines had pedigree information but only some were genotyped, with phenotypes from one or two environments in the 2011–2012 season, (ii) all lines had genotype and pedigree information and phenotypes from four or five environments in the 2012–2013 season, and (iii) the combination of Scenarios 1 and 2. Prediction accuracies were calculated by five‐fold cross validation on plant height, maturity, heading date, and grain yield. The single‐step HBLUP outperformed GBLUP and pedigree‐based ABLUP in all cases. We conclude that the single‐step procedure combining pedigree and genomic marker data should be favored where appropriate data is available for GP in wheat breeding programs.
6 March 2013 in Genetics Selection Evolution
Genomic prediction uses two sources of information: linkage disequilibrium between markers and quantitative trait loci, and additive genetic relationships between individuals. One way to increase the accuracy of genomic prediction is to capture more linkage disequilibrium by regression on haplotypes instead of regression on individual markers. The aim of this study was to investigate the accuracy of genomic prediction using haplotypes based on local genealogy information.