Using data from an outcrop characterization of a sandstone-rich turbidite channel fill (the so-called “Quarry outcrop” in the Ainsa basin), several stochastic facies models were constructed at bed-scale resolution (cells 2.5 m [8 ft] wide and 0.05 m [2 in.] thick). Several industry-standard reservoir-modeling algorithms were employed: truncated Gaussian simulation, sequential indicator simulation, multiple-point geostatistics, and object-based methods with varying degrees of complexity. The degree of similarity (i.e., realism) between realizations and the outcrop characterization was quantified through the use of several responses: (1) static connectivity, (2) effective permeability, and (3) recovery efficiency from waterflood simulations. Differences in the responses measured from the outcrop and facies models were observed: these are mostly algorithm related, instead of caused by soft data or different stochastic realizations. Differences increase greatly when the permeability of the heterolithic packages and mudstone beds (Ht-M) decreases and reflect the methods' ability to model the inclined and undulating Ht-M packages and beds that occur in the outcrop. These packages and beds can drape scours and sandstone beds with depositional topography and pinch-outs, producing sandstone thinning and dead ends. Object-based methods capable of introducing highly undulating Ht-M beds provided the most realistic models. Variogram-based and simple object-based methods failed to capture and reproduce the whole length of undulating beds. Multiple-point geostatistics provided realizations with responses intermediate between variogram-based and simple object-based methods and the more successful advanced object-based methods. The conditioning-to-hard-data capabilities of multiple-point geostatistics are higher than those of the object-based methods, which give them an added advantage.
1 January 2012 in International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control
Summary: In recent years, the impact of small-scale permeability structure on hydrocarbon recovery has been demonstrated, and upscaling procedures, such as the geopseudo method, have been developed to scale-up from the lamina scale using the hierarchy of geological length scales. However, upscaling is very time consuming, so many engineers still input rock curves into large-scale simulations. In this study, we show how the process may be speeded up using steady-state methods for calculating the pseudofunctions. Two examples are used to demonstrate the method. The first is a three-stage scale-up of a water flood in a fluvio-aeolian model. Capillary equilibrium was assumed for the first two stages, and viscous-dominated steady state for the third stage. Two different wettability cases were examined—water-wet and intermediate-wet. The effect of using the small-scale pseudo relative permeabilities depends on both the nature of the heterogeneities and on the wettability. In this study the recovery was reduced when small-scale pseudos were included, especially in the water-wet case. The second case study involved gas injection into the oil leg of a tidal deltaic reservoir. Scale-up was performed in two stages: (a) from the lithofacies scale to the geological model, and (b) from the geological model to the full-field simulation model. The viscous-dominated steady-state method was used in both cases. The results showed that the effect of the fine-scale heterogeneities was of the same order as the effect of the coarse-scale heterogeneity, indicating that (even in a system where capillary pressure is negligible) the fine-scale structure can be important.