According to cognitive-dissonance theory, performing counterattitudinal behavior produces a state of dissonance that people are motivated to resolve, usually by changing their attitude to be in line with their behavior. One of the most popular experimental paradigms used to produce such attitude change is the induced-compliance paradigm. Despite its popularity, the replication crisis in social psychology and other fields, as well as methodological limitations associated with the paradigm, raise concerns about the robustness of classic studies in this literature. We therefore conducted a multilab constructive replication of the induced-compliance paradigm based on Croyle and Cooper (Experiment 1). In a total of 39 labs from 19 countries and 14 languages, participants ( N = 4,898) were assigned to one of three conditions: writing a counterattitudinal essay under high choice, writing a counterattitudinal essay under low choice, or writing a neutral essay under high choice. The primary analyses failed to support the core hypothesis: No significant difference in attitude was observed after writing a counterattitudinal essay under high choice compared with low choice. However, we did observe a significant difference in attitude after writing a counterattitudinal essay compared with writing a neutral essay. Secondary analyses revealed the pattern of results to be robust to data exclusions, lab variability, and attitude assessment. Additional exploratory analyses were conducted to test predictions from cognitive-dissonance theory. Overall, the results call into question whether the induced-compliance paradigm provides robust evidence for cognitive dissonance.
1 October 2024 in Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science
In this commentary, we examine the implications of the failed replication reported by Vaidis et al., which represents the largest multilab attempt to replicate the induced-compliance paradigm in cognitive-dissonance theory. We respond to commentaries on this study and discuss potential explanations for the null findings, including issues with the perceived choice manipulation and various post hoc explanations. Our commentary includes an assessment of the broader landscape of cognitive-dissonance research, revealing pervasive methodological limitations, such as underpowered studies and a lack of open-science practices. We conclude that our replication study and our examination of the literature raise substantial concerns about the reliability of the induced-compliance paradigm and highlight the need for more rigorous research practices in the field of cognitive dissonance.
4 May 2023 in Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology
Comparative optimism is the self-advantageous tendency to think that positive events will happen to us more than to others and that negative events are more likely to happen to others than to oneself. This trend that values the self or values others less and requires a feeling of control is recurrent in Western societies. We assume that dominant neoliberal values in these societies facilitate the expression of comparative optimism. The main objective of the present study is to show that the priming of neoliberal values will promote the emergence of comparative optimism and internality. To achieve this goal, we primed neoliberal values using advertisements. In accordance with our main hypothesis, priming with neoliberal values had an indirect effect more on comparative optimism than neutral priming. Using manipulated variables, we confirmed the causal link between neoliberal values and the evaluation of one normative dimension of individualism (internality). The valorization of internality would appear to partially explain the link between neoliberal values and comparative optimism, confirming the support of our main hypothesis. The implications of these results are discussed from an ideological and socio-constructivist perspective.