Enhancing agricultural productivity through intercropping requires agronomic techniques such as timing the planting of legume crops, selecting fertilizer rate, and determining the proper proportion. A 2‐year field experiment was conducted in 2022 and 2023 to evaluate the effects of fertilizer rate, intercropping timing, and legume row arrangement on wheat–legume intercropping systems. The experiment included 2:1 and 3:1 wheat–legume row ratios. Wheat was spaced at 20 cm, while faba bean and lupin were spaced at 10 cm × 40 cm and 7 cm × 30 cm, respectively. Legumes were sown either simultaneously with wheat or 2 weeks after wheat planting. Sole wheat produced the highest grain yield (3.78 t ha −1 ). However, wheat grain yield in the treatment in which faba bean was sown 2 weeks after wheat at a 3:1 wheat‐to‐faba bean row ratio with recommended (100%) fertilizer rate was 3.61 t ha −1 , and this yield was statistically comparable to that of sole wheat ( p > 0.05). This intercropping system also produced the highest land equivalent ratio (LER) (1.87), wheat equivalent yield (WEY) (6.102 t ha −1 ), and economic returns. Accordingly, this study suggests that planting faba bean in 2 weeks after wheat in a 3:1 wheat‐to‐legume row ratio with100% fertilizer application as a viable intercropping practice for farmers in the northwestern Ethiopian highlands.