26 January 2023 in Forensic Science International
8 February 2019 in Journal of Forensic Sciences
3 November 2023 in Forensic Science International
8 August 2022 in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
Scientific principles of forensic source identification have attracted widespread interest in recent years. Among those presented principles and theorems, the Bayes inference was regarded as one of the most scientific principles. In this paper, we argue that the Bayes theorem is in challenge when used as principal basis for forensic source identification. Furthermore, two novel concepts: feature-matching value and feature-matching identification value are proposed inspired by the basic ideas of information theory. Based on these two concepts, a new framework is established to describe the source identification principles of forensic science. The proposed source identification principle uses deduction logic structure, and unifies the three existing source identification paradigms. The newly proposed framework is expected to provide a solid scientific basis for the source attribution methods in forensic science.
30 October 2026 in Forensic Science Advances
The rationale behind forensic science comparison methods is an important topic. The feature matching value framework proposed in 2022 is a new theory with competitive advantages, which may provide a scientific basis for feature comparison evaluation. In order to further clarify and enhance the scientific validity of this new theory, this paper studies its internal logic and scientific basis, and mathematically proves the form of feature matching value. Specifically, I carefully select the principles to be followed in the forensic science comparison method, establish them as a system of axioms (including 5 assumptions), and then derive the mathematical form of the concept of feature matching value from the axioms. Our work provides a scientific argument for the theory of forensic science comparison methodology, advancing from what it is to why.