Significance: Class I terpene synthases are essential in biosynthesis of bioactive terpenoids (e.g., Taxol). Identification of structure–function correlations is hampered by highly dynamic carbocation-driven reactions and the limited availability of catalytically relevant crystal structures. We provide the closed, catalytically active conformations of taxadiene synthase (TXS) and various taxonomically unrelated class I terpene synthases in complex with their catalytically relevant carbocationic intermediates. Our methodology allows direct prediction and validation of universal structural features that govern the highly dynamic catalytic processes of class I terpene synthases. Our data enabled delineation of a discrete reaction pathway for TXS and allowed targeted enzyme engineering to generate alternate macrocyclic core structures, which can act as synthons for bioactive lead structures.