1 January 2023 in Social Aspects of Population Health
MUMoscow Central Clinical Psychiatric Hospital Named After F.A. Usoltseva
Moscow Central Clinical Psychiatric Hospital Named After F.A. Usoltseva
Significance. The skills of effective doctor-patient communication are at the heart of a successful therapeutic process, enhancing diagnostic, medical and psychotherapeutic potentials of the treatment. Many leading medical schools have been actively studying the problems of communication in the process of medical consultation and developing their own communication models. This study intends to contribute to the elaboration of a similar model in the Russian Federation through identifying communication bottlenecks in a medical consultation. The purpose of the study is to analyze problems related to doctor-patient communication, assess satisfaction of doctors and patients with the quality of consultation in outpatient and inpatient facilities. Material and methods. The study was based on data analysis of 600 completed questionnaires (300 questionnaires for doctors and 300 questionnaires for patients), personally developed by the authors, based on key points of the most popular models of medical communication. Statistical data processing was performed using the SPSS STATISTICS 21.0 program. Results. The results obtained showed a number of defects in the doctor-patient communicative interaction during a medical consultation. For doctors working in a public hospital, the biggest problem was improper organization of the working day, while in a private hospital - establishing contact with the patient. Doctors in polyclinics rarely had the opportunity to discuss doubts and fears of the patient in both private and public organizations; while the patients were dissatisfied with the end of the consultation either. The patients singled out the following most problematic issues in the communication: the beginning of the consultation and the form of interaction in a public hospital, uncertainty in understanding a further plan of action and treatment, incomplete discussion of fears and expectations regarding their condition in a state polyclinic, and low degree of their involvement and understanding of peculiar features of the disease. Conclusion: difficulties in the communication process during a medical consultation exist both in medical organizations providing inpatient care and outpatient care, regardless of the form of ownership (public or private). The nature of the “communication error” differs across medical organizations. The survey made it possible to identify a number of communication problems that are essential for the successful implementation of the therapeutic process in patients, however, it had certain limitations due to specifics of the departments. The authors consider it expedient to conduct an expanded study within other departments of therapeutic, surgical, and rehabilitation profile.
19 January 2024 in Russian Family Doctor
BACKGROUND: Effective interaction between medical workers and patients is not only a service function but also influences compliance with the implementation of recommendations for the prevention and treatment of diseases. The communicative competence of healthcare professionals affects treatment effectiveness and the success of health-preserving measures. AIM: To examine the problems associated with the formation of communicative competence and determine the fundamental principles of the model of communicative skills of a medical worker. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A literature review of 32 domestic and 54 foreign publications on teaching communication in medicine was performed. The work of an expert focus group within the framework of a strategic session on communication skills “A coordinated approach to teaching communication skills in medicine” was analyzed. RESULTS: During the work of the focus group, experts reviewed and specified the main shortcomings in the work of medical personnel in ensuring communication with the patient. In the second part of the focus group work, based on communication defects, four blocks of skills were developed to avoid communication errors. Because of a review of literature data and a generalization of the results of the work of experts, a prototype model of the communication skills of a medical worker was proposed. CONCLUSIONS: Existing models of medical communication must adapt to national characteristics based on research and joint discussions. The authors propose using fundamental principles of the model of communication skills of a medical worker in educational programs of higher and additional professional education, as outlined in this article.
1 January 2022 in Medical Education and Professional Development
LULomonosov Moscow State University
Lomonosov Moscow State University
СОГЛАСОВАННЫЙ ПОДХОД В ОБУЧЕНИИ КОММУНИКАТИВНЫМ НАВЫКАМ В МЕДИЦИНСКОМ ОБРАЗОВАНИИ: БАРЬЕРЫ НА ПУТИ РЕАЛИЗАЦИИ
27 February 2025 in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
Professionally constructed communicative act allows to increase the confidence in doctor and compliance to treatment in patient, satisfaction with medical consultation of both participants, reduce the risk of emotional burnout and negligence of medical professional. Despite the active attention to the issue of communication in medicine and performance of numerous trainings, the problem persists regardless of doctor’s employment period in specialty, including due to the lack of communicative models that meet the needs of specialists. Objective. To study the influence of communicative model developed by the authors on the level of doctor’s and patient’s satisfaction with medical consultation; to identify the most problematic points of interaction for analysis and further improvement. Materials and methods. Doctors and patients were asked to assess their satisfaction with the medical consultation in the outpatient setting by filling out an authorial anonymous questionnaire twice before and after the training of doctors on the use of the communication model. At the first and second stages, 160 questionnaires were completed (80 questionnaires for doctors and 80 — for patients). The questionnaires were statistically processed, data were formed into graphs. Results. Satisfaction with medical consultation increased in both doctors and patients after the training completion. The most noticeable changes affected the beginning of consultation, logic and structure of discussions, increase of patient’s involvement and consultation summing up. Low scores were maintained in the evaluation of possibility of discussing the patient’s doubts, expectations and fears, so further research is needed. Additionally, a higher coincidence frequency of ratings by doctors and patients on similar questionnaire items has been noted. Conclusion. Following the proposed communicative model during the attendance has allowed to increase the doctor’s and patient’s satisfaction with medical consultation. Indirectly this result has an impact on the increase of patient’s compliance and reduction of doctor’s emotional burnout risk.
2 July 2024 in Virtual Technologies in Medicine
Communication skills are very important for establishing trust between medical staff and patients, increasing compliance, and ensuring a high level of quality of medical care. The article presents the results of a study during which a checklist for the supervision of a simulated patient during training on communication skills in medicine was developed. An expert assessment of the actions of a simulated patient using a developed checklist makes it possible to increase the effectiveness of training and the quality of the educational process.
13 September 2023 in Virtual Technologies in Medicine
In the Russian Federation various student Olympiads, skill competitions among specialists and other similar events are quite common. What are their goals and results, can the same be achieved differently, what are the pros and cons. Quite often these events are built exclusively on competitive conditions, which leads to undeserved victories for some and defeats for others, a shift in emphasis to external incentives, unnecessary separation of groups, and sometimes alienation and rejection of processes instead of attracting attention and development.