31 July 2024 in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
In a growing digital landscape, enhancing the discoverability and resonance of scientific articles is essential. Here, we offer 10 recommendations to amplify the discoverability of studies in search engines and databases. Particularly, we argue that the strategic use and placement of key terms in the title, abstract and keyword sections can boost indexing and appeal. By surveying 230 journals in ecology and evolutionary biology, we found that current author guidelines may unintentionally limit article findability. Our survey of 5323 studies revealed that authors frequently exhaust abstract word limits—particularly those capped under 250 words. This suggests that current guidelines may be overly restrictive and not optimized to increase the dissemination and discoverability of digital publications. Additionally, 92% of studies used redundant keywords in the title or abstract, undermining optimal indexing in databases. We encourage adopting structured abstracts to maximize the incorporation of key terms in titles, abstracts and keywords. In addition, we encourage the relaxation of abstract and keyword limitations in journals with strict guidelines, and the inclusion of multilingual abstracts to broaden global accessibility. These recommendations to editors are designed to improve article engagement and facilitate evidence synthesis, thereby aligning scientific publishing with the modern needs of academic research.
2 May 2025 in Global Change Biology
Heterogeneity is a defining feature of ecological and evolutionary meta‐analyses. While conventional meta‐analysis and meta‐regression methods acknowledge heterogeneity in effect sizes, they typically assume this heterogeneity is constant across studies and levels of moderators (i.e., homoscedasticity). This assumption could mask potentially informative patterns in the data. Here, we introduce and develop a location‐scale meta‐analysis and meta‐regression framework that models both the mean (location) and variance (scale) of effect sizes. Such a framework explicitly accommodates heteroscedasticity (differences in variance), thereby revealing when and why heterogeneity itself changes. This capability, we argue, is crucial for understanding responses to global environmental change, where complex, context‐dependent processes may shape both the average magnitude and the variability of biological responses. For example, differences in study design, measurement protocols, environmental factors, or even evolutionary history can lead to systematic shifts in variance. By incorporating hierarchical (multilevel) structures and phylogenetic relationships, location‐scale models can disentangle the contributions from different levels to both location and scale parts. We further attempt to extend the concepts of relative heterogeneity and publication bias into the scale part of meta‐regression. With these methodological advances, we can identify patterns and processes that remain obscured under the constant variance assumption, thereby enhancing the biological interpretability and practical relevance of meta‐analytic results. Notably, almost all published ecological and evolutionary meta‐analytic data can be re‐analysed using our proposed analytic framework to gain new insights. Altogether, location‐scale meta‐analysis and meta‐regression provide a rich and holistic lens through which to view and interpret the intricate tapestry woven with ecological and evolutionary data. The proposed approach, thus, ultimately leads to more informed and context‐specific conclusions about environmental changes and their impacts.
28 January 2026 in Journal of The Royal Society Interface
Repeatability, more generally known as intraclass correlation, represents an important quantity of interest in many scientific fields. It represents a metric for summarizing variance decomposition to identify sources of variation in an outcome of interest (e.g. organismal traits). The estimation of variance components is often achieved through linear mixed-effects models or their extension, generalized linear mixed-effects models. Here, we review variants of calculating repeatabilities from mixed-effects models for a variety of conditions and applications. We also recommend which variant might be appropriate under what conditions, focusing on behavioural biology/ecology examples. However, the decision is ultimately with the researcher, since it depends upon their research question, and there is no one-size-fits-all solution. We also highlight the importance of the scope of inference, which affects how repeatabilities are used and interpreted. We recommend transparent reporting of statistical results, including all variance components, which are the building blocks of repeatability. This review aims to assist empiricists in choosing an appropriate repeatability variant and interpretation concerning their questions and the scope of inference.
1 October 2025 in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Understanding how both the mean ( location ) and variance ( scale ) of traits differ among species and lineages is fundamental to unveiling macroevolutionary patterns. Yet, traditional phylogenetic comparative methods primarily focus on modelling mean trait values, often overlooking variability and heteroscedasticity that can provide critical insights into evolutionary dynamics. Here, we introduce phylogenetic location–scale models (PLSMs), a novel framework that jointly analyses the evolution of trait means and variances. This dual approach captures heteroscedasticity and evolutionary changes in trait variability, allowing for the detection of clades with differing variances and revealing patterns of adaptation, diversification, and evolutionary constraints. Extending PLSMs to a multivariate context enables simultaneous analysis of multiple traits and their covariances, facilitating the testing of hypotheses about evolutionary trade‐offs, pleiotropy and phenotypic integration. By modelling covariances between phylogenetic effects in both the location and scale parts, we can discern whether changes in one trait's mean or variance are associated with changes in another's, thereby offering deeper insights into the mechanisms driving trait co‐evolution and co‐divergence or ‘contra‐divergence’. We also describe how an extended version of PLSMs incorporating within‐species variability can enhance our understanding of trait convergence and divergence arising from ecological and environmental factors. Our framework provides a powerful tool for exploring macroevolutionary patterns and can be used to reassess previously published comparative data, offering new insights into the mechanisms driving the diversity of life.
18 August 2025 in Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews
Meta-analyses play an important role in empirically synthesising research and guiding future directions. The field of animal cognition is rapidly expanding, with both empirical and review papers increasing at a faster rate than those in the life sciences overall. However, the use of meta-analyses, their methodological rigour, and the geographic distribution of research activity remain unclear. We systematically reviewed 49 meta-analytical studies encompassing 1824 primary studies on animal cognition. Half of the meta-analytical studies focused on the evolution and diversity of non-human animal cognition, while the other half used animals as models to understand human cognition. Most studies addressed factors affecting cognitive abilities, focusing on mammals and birds. Although many studies aimed to examine evolutionary or diversity-related questions, few analysed cognitive variation across species or tested evolutionary hypotheses, and even fewer incorporated phylogenetic relationships. While some studies investigated sex differences, many reported that they could not due to unbalanced sex ratios in the primary studies, notably a predominance of males. Both primary and meta-analytical studies often lacked adequate methodological reporting and rarely shared raw data or analysis scripts. Our bibliometric analysis showed that research is geographically concentrated, with authorship and collaboration mostly in high-income countries. To address current gaps, we recommend greater adherence to open science practices, improved regional inclusivity, and broader taxonomic and individual-level coverage. Finally, we highlight the complementary roles of meta-analyses and Big Team Science in advancing the field by improving its transparency, inclusivity, and reliability.
18 October 2023 in Royal Society Open Science
The diverse characteristics of animal signal designs can be explained by the sensory bias hypothesis, which suggests that natural selection shapes sensory bias and preferences associated with signal design. Traditionally, this hypothesis has focused on female sensory biases and male sexual traits. However, considering shared sensory systems between males and females in non-sexual contexts, existing sensory bias possibly contributes to the evolution of shared social and sexual traits. Our previous studies on the family Estrildidae supported this idea. An evolutionary relationship probably existed between diet and white dot plumage, and a species of estrildid finches showed a visual preference for white dot patterns. To investigate this further, we examined hunger-related visual preferences using phylogenetic comparative methods and behavioural experiments. Specifically, we compared the gazing responses of 12 species of estrildids to monochromatic printed white dot and stripe patterns, considering their phylogenetic relationships. The results support our idea that the common estrildid ancestor had a hunger-related visual preference for white dot patterns. Subject species generally preferred white dots to stripes. Furthermore, males and females showed a similar preference towards dots. Our findings provide insights into the role of sensory bias in the evolution of mutual ornamentation.