5 September 2026 in ACM Transactions on Knowledge Discovery From Data
Reliably inferring causal effects from observational data is a cornerstone of scientific inquiry and data-driven decision-making, yet its validity is frequently undermined by the inappropriate selection of covariates. Standard adjustment methods often operate on the fragile assumption that all observed covariates are beneficial confounders, a premise that is rarely tenable in high-dimensional settings. The uncritical inclusion of non-confounding variables can introduce significant estimation bias, leading to flawed scientific conclusions and ineffective policies. To confront this foundational challenge, we first introduce the Adjustment by Proxy framework, a unified analytical lens to systematically diagnose the bias introduced by distinct classes of non-confounding covariates. This framework enables a rigorous theoretical derivation of the harm caused by including variables such as instruments, colliders, or mediators. Building upon this diagnostic foundation, we then propose a novel graph-based criterion demonstrating that the Proximal Confounder Set, defined as the minimal set of confounders that d-separates the treatment from all other confounders, constitutes a minimal and theoretically optimal adjustment set for causal effect inference. Extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world benchmark datasets validate our theoretical claims, demonstrating that adjusting on the Proximal Confounder Set yields consistently more accurate causal estimates than conventional strategies. Together, these contributions provide a rigorous and practical guide for covariate selection, paving the way for more robust and automated causal inference.