The Address Resolution Protocol (ARP) enables communication between IP-speaking nodes in a local network by reconstructing the hardware (MAC) address associated with the IP address of an interface. This is not needed in a Software-Defined Network (SDN), because each device can forward packets without the need to learn this association. We tackle the interoperability problem arising between standard network devices (end systems, routers), that rely on ARP, and SDN datapaths, that do not handle ARP packets natively. In particular, we propose a general approach to handle ARP in a SDN, that is applicable in several network scenarios, is transparent for existing devices, and can coexist with any packet forwarding logic implemented in the controller. Our approach reduces ARP traffic by confining it to the edge of SDNs and requires a minimal set of flow entries in the datapaths. We argument about its applicability and confirm it with experiments performed on SDN datapaths from a range of different vendors.
Software-Defined Networking (SDN) is a de-facto established approach that separates the packet switching functions of a device from its operational logic, which is controlled by a piece of software. Due to its potential for realizing new network architectures and services, a whole thread of scientific literature is devoted to SDN and its most adopted incarnation, OpenFlow. However, limited attention has been put in verifying the viability of the proposed approaches on currently available hardware. We address this deficiency through the following contributions: i) a critical review of the literature about SDN in terms of applicability issues stemming from publicly documented limitations of OpenFlow implementations; ii) a methodology for verifying the support of SDN-related functions in a network device, comprising an OpenFlow compliance test as well as custom targeted tests; iii) an application of the methodology to devices from 7 different vendors, unveiling extensive anomalous behaviors affecting even the most basic features; iv) a discussion of this outcome in terms of relevance of the discovered anomalies and of their implications on the applicability of state-of-the-art contributions on SDN. Besides taking a snapshot of the viability of research results, with this paper we intend to highlight aspects that operators should consider when picking SDN devices.
Internet Exchange Points (IXPs) play a crucial role in the Internet ecosystem. However, existing literature fails in quantitatively assessing the advantage for an Internet Service Provider (ISP) to peer at an IXP. We give a contribution to bridge such a gap by collaborating with three medium-sized ISPs in Italy to compare key performance indicators (round-trip delay, hop count, packet loss, and jitter) as measured from several vantage points in presence and absence of IXP peerings. Our findings are that IXP-based paths exhibit better and more stable performance, whereas avoiding IXPs introduces performance deterioration and higher variability. Moreover, our measurements confirm that IXP-based paths tend to preserve the locality of traffic.
Federated networking is a promising approach to resource sharing that supports cost-effective services involving multiple parties. Research in this field largely focused on architectures and cost models, making limited progress on the technological side. On the other hand, the widely adopted Software-Defined Networking (SDN) model found its most successful application in data centers, exhibiting very little penetration in other scenarios. We leverage the unexplored potential of SDN on the edge of a network to introduce an approach that supports end-to-end connectivity among different federated partners. Our approach is based on simple Network Address and Port Translation (NAPT), making it applicable in standard IP networks. It is also very flexible, because it exploits SDN, and scalable, because address translations are performed on Customer Premises Equipment, where SDN is being progressively supported by device vendors. We define various alternative NAPT strategies and evaluate their effectiveness with simulations as well as emulated scenarios.